| Achievement | How to unlock | Points
|
|---|
| - Complete 10 Pounds of Gold with 5 Different Wrestlers
| |
| - Win a match as Matt Cardona
| |
| - Successfully Defend a Championship in Exhibition Mode
| |
| - Win a 4 Way Elimination Match
| |
| - Complete Your First Match
| |
| - Defeat Your Opponent Within 3 minutes Inside a Steel Cage
| |
| - Win a match as Colt Cabana
| |
| | |
| | |
| - Win a match as Nick Aldis against Austin Idol in the NWA Power arena
| |
| - Win a match as Zack Sabre Jr. by submission
| |
| - Win a Falls Count Anywhere Match Outside the Ring
| |
- I Don't Think So, Brother!
| - Win a Match After Triggering a Second Wind
| |
- I Have Sailed the World, Beheld Its Wonders
| - Win a match in every arena
| |
- I Hope The Ref Didn't See That
| - Hit Your Opponent With a Steel Chair
| |
- I'll Take 'em Both, I'm Hardcore
| - Win a 3 Way Match with Tommy Dreamer in the Ballroom
| |
| - Watch Five AI vs. AI Battles
| |
| - Win a match as Tommy Dreamer
| |
| - Win a match as Nikita Koloff in the NWA 70 Arena
| |
| - Kick Out of Your Opponent's Finishing Move
| |
| - Complete The Basic Tutorial in Story Mode
| |
| | |
| - Win a Tag match as Cardona & Myers in the STOMP In Paradise Arena
| |
| - Win a match as Nick Aldis
| |
| - Land 3 Finishing Moves in One Match
| |
| - Win a Cage Match inside the "Chain Link" cage
| |
- Retromania World Champion
| | |
| | |
| | |
- That's Why They Call It High Risk
| - Miss an Attack from the Top of the Cage
| |
- The Best-ler, Better Than All the Rest-ler
| | |
- The Most Professional Wrestler
| - Win a match as Brian Myers
| |
- The Real Star of the Show
| - Win a match as Johnny Retro
| |
- The Real World's Champion
| - Complete 10 Pounds of Gold Mode
| |
| - Win a Cage Match inside the "Big Blue" cage
| |
| - Win a 6 Man Tag Team Match as the Blue World Order
| |
| - Win a match as Warhorse in Warhorse's Hell Arena
| |
| - Win a Tag Team match as Hawk & Animal
| |
| - Win a match as Stevie Richards in the SRF Arena
| |
