| Achievement | How to unlock | Points
|
|---|
| 5 Time, 5 Time, 5 Time | Complete 10 Pounds of Gold with 5 Different Wrestlers | 25
|
| Alwayz Ready | Win a match as Matt Cardona | 15
|
| And Still | Successfully Defend a Championship in Exhibition Mode | 25
|
| And Then There Was One | Win a 4 Way Elimination Match | 25
|
| Big Debut! | Complete Your First Match | 15
|
| Bonesaw is Ready! | Defeat Your Opponent Within 3 minutes Inside a Steel Cage | 25
|
| Boom Boom! | Win a match as Colt Cabana | 15
|
| Can't win 'em All | Lose 10 Matches | 15
|
| Established Talent | Win 20 matches | 25
|
| Generation Clash | Win a match as Nick Aldis against Austin Idol in the NWA Power arena | 15
|
| Hurrah! Another Trophy! | Win a match as Zack Sabre Jr. by submission | 15
|
| I Don't Need The Ring! | Win a Falls Count Anywhere Match Outside the Ring | 15
|
| I Don't Think So, Brother! | Win a Match After Triggering a Second Wind | 15
|
| I Have Sailed the World, Beheld Its Wonders | Win a match in every arena | 50
|
| I Hope The Ref Didn't See That | Hit Your Opponent With a Steel Chair | 15
|
| I'll Take 'em Both, I'm Hardcore | Win a 3 Way Match with Tommy Dreamer in the Ballroom | 25
|
| I'm Just a Spectator | Watch Five AI vs. AI Battles | 15
|
| Innovator of Violence | Win a match as Tommy Dreamer | 15
|
| Kickin' it Old School | Win a match as Nikita Koloff in the NWA 70 Arena | 15
|
| Killin' the Biz | Kick Out of Your Opponent's Finishing Move | 25
|
| Learn the Ropes, Kid | Complete The Basic Tutorial in Story Mode | 10
|
| Main Eventer | Win 50 matches | 25
|
| Major Marks | Win a Tag match as Cardona & Myers in the STOMP In Paradise Arena | 25
|
| National Treasure | Win a match as Nick Aldis | 15
|
| No One Gets Up From That | Land 3 Finishing Moves in One Match | 25
|
| Nowhere To Run | Win a Cage Match inside the "Chain Link" cage | 15
|
| Retromania World Champion | Earn All Other Trophies | 200
|
| SPLX King | Win a match as Jeff Cobb | 15
|
| Skinning the Cat | Win a Retro Rumble | 50
|
| That's Why They Call It High Risk | Miss an Attack from the Top of the Cage | 15
|
| The Best-ler, Better Than All the Rest-ler | Complete the Story mode | 50
|
| The Most Professional Wrestler | Win a match as Brian Myers | 15
|
| The Real Star of the Show | Win a match as Johnny Retro | 15
|
| The Real World's Champion | Complete 10 Pounds of Gold Mode | 25
|
| Unforgiving Steel | Win a Cage Match inside the "Big Blue" cage | 15
|
| We're Takin' Over! | Win a 6 Man Tag Team Match as the Blue World Order | 25
|
| What Is Going On Here? | Win a match as Warhorse in Warhorse's Hell Arena | 15
|
| What a Rush! | Win a Tag Team match as Hawk & Animal | 25
|
| Whipped Into Shape | Win a match as Stevie Richards in the SRF Arena | 15
|