| Award | How to unlock | 
|---|
|  | Win a match when your partner has less than 25% health remaining (tag team match). 
 | 
|  | Successfully complete a corner grapple on all four corners. 
 | 
|  | Pick up downed opponent five times. 
 | 
|  | Take finishing moves from opponent and win. 
 | 
|  | Bust a sledgehammer on opponent. 
 | 
|  | Execute five environmental grapples. 
 | 
|  | Execute seven submission moves to an opponent's torso. 
 | 
|  | Bloody both opponents (tag team match). 
 | 
|  | Get tired enough to fall down. 
 | 
|  |  | 
|  | Win a match with less than 10% health. 
 | 
|  | Taunt six times while out of the ring. 
 | 
|  | Consume 400 units of stamina. 
 | 
|  | Successfully complete twenty quick grapples. 
 | 
|  | Pump up the crowd five times as the illegal partner (tag team match). 
 | 
|  | Argue with the ref four times. 
 | 
|  | Manually halt the ref's pinfall count four times. 
 | 
|  | Perform your finisher four times. 
 | 
|  | Spend over thirty seconds fighting outside the ring. 
 | 
|  | Bust a barbed wire 2x4 on an opponent. 
 | 
|  | Defeat a super-heavyweight in two and a half minutes or less while playing as a cruiser. 
 | 
|  | Destroy all the announcer tables. 
 | 
|  | Defeat a super-heavyweight in two and half minutes or less while playing as a diva. 
 | 
|  | Win a match with less than 50% health. 
 | 
|  | Successfully complete ten running grapples. 
 | 
|  | Bust a trash can on opponent. 
 | 
|  | Perform two finishers outside the ring. 
 | 
|  | Let top-momentum timer expire three times. 
 | 
|  | Climb the top rope four times and jump down rather than attacking. 
 | 
|  | Hit top rope moves off every corner. 
 | 
|  | Connect with ten attacks off the top rope. 
 | 
|  | Successfully taunt your opponent eight times. 
 | 
|  | Stay out of the ring until the ref's nine-count. 
 | 
|  | Do not use a strike the entire match. 
 | 
|  | Connect with twelve standing strikes. 
 | 
|  | Distract referee four times (tag team match). 
 | 
|  | Hit top rope move to an opponent at ringside. 
 | 
|  | Perform five submission holds while out of the ring. 
 | 
|  | Counter two finisher attempts. 
 | 
|  | Block or counter at least ten attacks/grapples. 
 | 
|  | Execute five total control grapples. 
 | 
|  | Successfully taunt your opponent four times. 
 | 
|  | Successfully complete a match without taking damage. 
 | 
|  | Win with very little momentum. 
 | 
|  | Escap four Struggle submissions during a match. 
 | 
|  | Only use a total of three different attacks or grapples for the whole match. 
 | 
|  |  | 
|  | Connect with five attacks off the top rope. 
 | 
|  | Win without going for a single pin attempt. 
 | 
|  | Strike opponent with five different objects. 
 | 
|  | Bust a chair on opponent. 
 | 
|  | Reverse/counter every attack/grapple in a match. 
 | 
|  | Win in less than two and a half minutes. 
 | 
|  | Spend two minutes fighting outside of the ring. 
 | 
|  | Do not use a grapple the entire match. 
 | 
|  | Use one attack or grapple exclusively for an entire match. 
 | 
|  | Break out of three total control grapples by an opponent. 
 | 
|  | Come up short looking for object under ring. 
 | 
|  | Execute seven submission moves to an opponent's neck. 
 | 
|  |  | 
|  | Successfully complete all your Superstar's signatures and finishers. 
 | 
|  | Win while both you and opponent were bloody. 
 | 
|  | Execute a submission move to every part of an opponent's body. 
 | 
|  | Execute two grapples against the security barricade. 
 | 
|  | Win a match after being bloodied. 
 | 
|  | Manually release six Struggle submissions (no rope break). 
 | 
|  | Successfully complete four strikes/grapples from the apron (tag team match). 
 | 
|  | Bust a Singapore cane on opponent. 
 | 
|  | Irish Whip opponent into corner ten times. 
 | 
|  | Successfully complete 35 strikes. 
 | 
|  | Win with 85% of your total health. 
 | 
|  | Knock opponent down and never let them back up. 
 | 
|  | Win despite being hit with three different objects. 
 | 
|  | Connect with eight strikes with opponent is in the corner. 
 | 
|  | Execute five strong grapples. 
 | 
|  | Successfully complete ten running attacks. 
 | 
|  | Win without sustaining yellow limb damage anywhere. 
 | 
|  | Execute seven submission holds to an opponent's leg. 
 | 
|  | Lock on a submission move while opponent is on an announcer table. 
 | 
|  | Win a match when you have 33% health or less and your partner has 75% health or more (tag team match). 
 | 
|  | Irish Whip opponent outside ring three times. 
 | 
|  | Execute seven submission holds to an opponent's arms. 
 | 
|  | Have a taunt interrupted by an opponent three times. 
 | 
|  | Execute five signature moves. 
 | 
|  | Make an opponent bleed within one minute. 
 | 
|  | Perform your finisher eight times. 
 | 
|  |  | 
|  | Win by pinfall after five two-counts by either superstar. 
 | 
|  | Win despite being put through a table (including announce table). 
 | 
|  | Win while only being countered/revered three or fewer times. 
 | 
|  | Destroy one of the announcer tables. 
 | 
|  | Perform seven double-team moves (tag team match). 
 | 
|  | Irish Whip opponent five times. 
 | 
|  | Break up three taunt attempts by your opponent. 
 | 
|  | Take an opponent's object three times.
 |