| Achievement | How to unlock | Points
|
|---|
| - Complete "At Home with Dutch".
| |
- All's Right With the World
| - Complete "On a Pale Horse".
| |
| - Complete Twin Rocks, Pike's Basin, and Gaptooth Breach Hideouts.
| |
| - Complete all Tomahawk challenges.
| |
| - Kill and skin eighteen grizzly bears.
| |
| - Break the Kentucky Saddler, the American Standardbred, and the Hungarian Half-bred.
| |
| - Get 250 headshots in any game mode.
| |
| - Find and kill a chupacabra.
| |
| | |
| - Place a hogtied woman on the train tracks, and witness her death by train.
| |
| - Complete Tumbleweed and Tesoro Azul Hideouts.
| |
| - Purchase a rare weapon from a gunsmith.
| |
| - Find and break a unicorn.
| |
- Fightin' Around the World
| - Knock someone out in melee in every saloon in the game.
| |
| - Use a pardon letter with more than $5000 bounty.
| |
| - Obtain Legendary rank in any Ambient Challenge.
| |
| - Earn a Gold Medal Rank for a combat mission.
| |
| | |
- Heading South on a White Bronco
| - Evade the US Marshals while riding the Hungarian Half-Bred horse.
| |
| - Win over 2000 chips in a hand of Poker.
| |
| - Kill 500 enemies with any pistol or revolver in any game mode.
| |
| - Complete Fort Mercer and Nosalida Hideouts.
| |
| - Complete "The Last Enemy That Shall Be Destroyed".
| |
| - Complete "Cure For Most of What Ails You" and "Get Back in that Hole, Partner" Survivor Missions.
| |
| - Complete "The Assault on Fort Mercer".
| |
| - Kill 500 enemies with any rifle, repeater, or shotgun in any game mode.
| |
- Mad Marston: The Trail Warrior
| - Attain Rank 5 in all Undead Nightmare Challenges.
| |
- Man of Honor / Chivalry's Dead
| - Attain highest Fame rank and either highest Honor rank or lowest Honor rank.
| |
| - Kill the last buffalo in the Great Plains.
| |
| - Complete the Explosive Rifle Challenge.
| |
| | |
| - Kill 500 enemies with a mounted weapon in any game mode.
| |
| - Complete a game of Liar's Dice without losing a single die.
| |
| - Complete "An Appointed Time".
| |
| - Complete "Remember My Family".
| |
| - Uncover every location on the map.
| |
| - Complete fifteen tasks for Strangers.
| |
| - Attain 100% in the Game Completion stat.
| |
| - Find and kill a sasquatch.
| |
| - Complete "The Gates of El Presidio".
| |
| - Have every territory saved at the same time during the Undead Nightmare.
| |
| - Complete twenty story missions without switching to a new horse at a hitching post.
| |
| - Complete a task for a Stranger.
| |
| - Complete "Exodus in America".
| |
- The Benefits of Civilization
| - Complete "And the Truth Will Set You Free".
| |
| - Complete "Curious Tales from Blackwater, USA" Survivor Mission.
| |
| - Score a headshot on any enemy using Expert targeting mode.
| |
| - Complete "Mother Superior Blues Survivor Mission".
| |
| - Kill one of every animal species in the game in any game mode.
| |
- What About Hand Grenades?
| - Get a ringer in a game of Horseshoes.
| |
| - Attain 100% Game Completion statistic in Undead Nightmare.
| |
