| Achievement | How to unlock | Points
|
|---|
| ... And Where Do the Stories Come From? | Raid a town. | 22
|
| A New Legend Awaits | Finish the main storyline. | 68
|
| A True Dandy | Achieve full approval from two nations. | 44
|
| After All, Why Shouldn't I Keep It? | Have possessed all types of ships. | 44
|
| But You Have Heard of Me | Lose a sea battle. | 22
|
| Curse of the Seven Seas | Reach level 25 with your character. | 44
|
| Devilishly Talented | Raid 666 convoys in one game. | 44
|
| Double the Barrels, double the Fun | Fire both broadsides in one round. | 22
|
| Eeligally Ambitious | Win your first sea battle. | 22
|
| Fishing for Compliments | Have over 80% loyalty from at least five captains at the same time. | 68
|
| Head First | Ram the entirety of a convoy. | 22
|
| Heavy Tunaing | Fully equip a Ship of the line exclusively with the best gear. | 44
|
| House Party! | Possess a hideout. | 22
|
| I'm Somewhat of a Colonial Force Myself | Possess six hideouts. | 44
|
| Make It Rain | Distribute 1,000,000 Gold when dividing booty. | 68
|
| Morally Flexible | Complete a mission for each faction. | 44
|
| No Half Measures | Sink the entirety of a convoy. | 22
|
| O Captain! My Captain! | Complete all captain's adventures. | 68
|
| Oooh, We're Half Way There | Complete five captain's adventures. | 44
|
| Personal Matter | Board a ship. | 22
|
| Pimp My Glide | Upgrade a ship at the harbormaster. | 22
|
| Pirate King | Possess all hideouts. | 68
|
| Pufferfish | Capture 10,000 barrels of hemp in one game. | 22
|
| Sharing Is Caring | Share your entire booty. | 44
|
| Table for Six | Sail with six captains. | 22
|
| To the World's End | Complete one captain's adventure. | 22
|