| Achievement | How to unlock | Points
|
|---|
| Day Route | You got Day's ending. | 100
|
| First Day of School | Attend the first day of Senior year. | 50
|
| Flight of the Fae | You are a fae expert. | 100
|
| It's Good, Actually | Not a bad first mixed drink! | 100
|
| More than Bandmates | Taylor opened up about the true nature of his relationship with Brandon. | 100
|
| Oops, All Cindys | You picked the same name as your mark. | 100
|
| Robert Route | You got Robert's ending. | 100
|
| Taylor Route | You got Taylor's ending. | 100
|
| That's a Reference | We would definitely love these two. | 100
|
| The Queens of Pranks | You got back at the Pranktor! | 100
|
| Welcome to Ladle | You've moved in to Ladle. Welcome! | 50
|