| Trophy | How to unlock
|
|---|
| Apple Cup | University of Washington Huskies vs. Washington State University Cougars
|
| Battle of I-25 Trophy | New Mexico vs. New Mexico State
|
| Bayou Bucket | Houston Cougars vs. Rice Owls
|
| Beehive Boot | Utah vs. Brigham Young vs. Utah State vs. Weber State
|
| Bronze Boot | Colorado State University vs. University of Wyoming
|
| Commander in Chief | Army vs. Navy vs. Air Force
|
| Commonwealth Cup | University of Virginia Cavaliers vs. Virginia Tech Hokies
|
| Cy-Hawk Trophy | Iowa Hawkeyes vs. Iowa State Cyclones
|
| Floyd of Rosedale | University of Minnesota Gophers vs. Iowa Hawkeyes
|
| Fremont Cannon | Nevada Wolf Pack vs. UNLV Rebels
|
| Golden Boot | University of Arkansas Razorbacks vs. LSU Tigers
|
| Golden Egg Trophy | Ole Miss Rebels vs. Mississippi State
|
| Golden Hat | Texas Longhorns vs. Oklahoma Sooners
|
| Governor's Cup | Brown University vs. University of Rhode Island or Georgia Tech vs. University of Georgia
|
| Governor's Victory Bell | Minnesota vs. Penn State
|
| Illibuck | Ohio State Buckeyes vs. Illinois Fighting Illini
|
| Ireland Trophy | Boston College vs. Notre Dame
|
| Iron Skillet | South Methodist University Mustangs vs. Texas Christian University Horned Frogs
|
| Jeweled Shillelagh | Purdue vs. Notre Dame
|
| Keg of Nails | Cincinnati Bearcats vs. Louisville Cardinals
|
| Land Grant Trophy | Penn State vs. Michigan State
|
| Little Brown Jug | Minnesota vs. University of Michigan
|
| Marching Drum | Kansas vs. Missouri
|
| Megaphone | Notre Dame vs. Michigan State
|
| Missouri-Nebraska Bell | Missouri vs. Nebraska
|
| ODK: FOY Sportsmanship Trophy | Alabama vs. Auburn
|
| Old Oaken Bucket | Indiana vs. Purdue
|
| Paul Bunyan Trophy | Michigan vs. Michigan State
|
| Paul Bunyan's Axe | Minnesota vs. Wisconsin
|
| Peace Pipe | Bowling Green vs. Toledo
|
| Purdue Cannon | Purdue vs. Illinois
|
| Seminole War Canoe | Florida vs. Miami
|
| Shillelagh Trophy | Notre Dame vs. Purdue
|
| Silver Spade | New Mexico State vs. UTEP
|
| Stanford Axe | Cal vs. Stanford
|
| Telephone Trophy | Iowa State vs. Missouri
|
| Territorial Cup | Arizona vs. Arizona State
|
| Textile Bowl Trophy | Clemson vs. NC State
|
| Tiger Rag | LSU vs. Tulane
|
| Victory Bell | Miami University Red Hawks vs. Cincinnati Bearcats
|
| Victory Bell | UCLA vs. USC
|
| Victory Bell | Missouri Tigers vs. Nebraska Cornhuskers
|
| Wagon Wheel | Akron vs. Kent State
|
| Williams Trophy | Rice vs. Tulsa
|