| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| #Ego99Challenge | Win a single 9+ inning game on Ego 99 between two Standard teams (vs CPU only). | Gold
|
| Age of Alumni | Hit a home run with a Legends League player. | Bronze
|
| Alchemist | Sign a player in Franchise mode who boosts a Chemistry to the highest level. | Bronze
|
| Best of the Best | Win a championship in standard Franchise, Season, or Elimination with a Legends League team. | Silver
|
| Clank! | Take a comebacker to the head with a pitcher who has the Metal Head Trait. | Bronze
|
| Crowd Pleaser | Hit a walk-off home run with a player whose Mojo is On Fire or Jacked (vs CPU only). | Bronze
|
| Cycle | Hit for the cycle (a player records a single, double, triple, and home run) (vs CPU only). | Silver
|
| Draft Punk | Complete a Shuffle Draft with a Draft Pool consisting of players from multiple leagues. | Bronze
|
| El Grande | Strike out five hitters in two innings (vs CPU only). | Bronze
|
| Gobsmacked! | Hit a 500+ ft home run. | Silver
|
| It's Past Your Bedtime! | Play extra innings during a night game. | Bronze
|
| Janitor | Record an outfield assist with a player who has the Cannon Arm Trait (vs CPU only). | Bronze
|
| Leap of Faith | Rob a home run with a jumping wall catch. | Bronze
|
| Like Father Like Son | In a single game, hit a home run with both Junior Young Jr and Junior Young Sr. | Bronze
|
| Meltdown | Trigger the Meltdown trait for the opposing pitcher (vs CPU only). | Bronze
|
| No No | Throw a 9+ inning no-hitter in standard Franchise, Season, or Elimination (standard teams only). | Silver
|
| Not so Fast | Finish a double play on a grounder before a hitter with 90+ Speed reaches 1B (vs CPU only) | Bronze
|
| OGs For Three | Hit three home runs in a single game with the Originators. | Bronze
|
| Oh Baby a Triple | Turn a triple play (vs CPU only). | Silver
|
| Perfecto | Throw a 9+ inning perfect game in standard Franchise, Season, or Elimination (standard teams only). | Gold
|
| Pick Off Artist | Pick off a runner (vs CPU only). | Bronze
|
| Predictable | Hit a home run against a pitch enhanced by an Elite Pitch Trait (vs CPU only). | Bronze
|
| Rented Mule | Pitch a 9+ inning complete game with a pitcher who has the Workhorse Trait (vs CPU only). | Bronze
|
| SMB4 Champ | Win a standard Elimination with a standard team and a tournament average Ego of 90+. | Gold
|
| SMB4 Hall of Fame | Obtain all trophies. | Platinum
|
| SMB4 Master | Win a standard Season or Franchise postseason with a standard team and a season average Ego of 80+. | Gold
|
| See You Next Time! | Hit a walk-off home run in a standard playoff or Elimination game (standard teams only). | Silver
|
| Sir Immaculo | Throw an immaculate inning (three strikeouts in nine pitches) (vs CPU only). | Silver
|
| Star Outfielder | Turn a double play after an outfielder makes a diving catch for an out (vs CPU only). | Silver
|
| Talent Scout | Complete a Shuffle Draft with a team that has at least 10 Traits at their highest level. | Bronze
|
| Taters! | Hit two 450+ ft home runs in one game. | Bronze
|
| Touch Grass | Win a game in every stadium. | Bronze
|
| Trash Bang | Hit a home run immediately after the Sign Stealer Trait activates (vs CPU only). | Silver
|
| Triple Crown | Win the Triple Crown (AVG, HR, RBI) in a standard Season or Franchise (standard teams only). | Silver
|
| You Complete Me | Throw a 9+ inning complete game shutout (vs CPU only). | Bronze
|