| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| "The rotation of the earth, really makes my day" | Solve the Winans Piece Puzzle. | Gold
|
| Dialogue wizard | Answer properly to an unheard question. | Gold
|
| First sighting | See a winged creature. | Silver
|
| Illusion of control | Sort shelves. | Silver
|
| Macho cry | Cry your heart out. | Gold
|
| No secrets | Find out Lee's business with Holt. | Gold
|
| Not just marvellous... | Watch the credits until the end. | Gold
|
| Platinum Mothmen! | Unlock all trophies in Mothmen 1966. | Platinum
|
| Puzzle historian | Listen about the L's. | Gold
|
| Reliable witness | Make a creature's accurate drawing. | Gold
|
| Solitaire's bad run | Lose with more than 25 cards to go. | Silver
|
| Solitaire's good run | Lose with 15 or less cards to go. | Gold
|
| Sudden endings completist | Die all possible deaths. | Gold
|
| They hunt in packs | Survive the coyote attack. | Silver
|
| Unreliable witness | Make a really inaccurate drawing. | Silver
|
| Winans last stand | Survive all cryptid waves. | Gold
|