| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| 25-Ever | As a team, get 25 total bases in a single game (excludes simulated gameplay). | Gold
|
| A New Perspective | While in player lock, utilize the first-person camera to make an out. | Bronze
|
| A Show Token a Day... | Earn at least two Show Tokens from a single game in RTTS. | Silver
|
| Building an Empire | Create a custom team in Franchise or MTO. | Bronze
|
| By Any Means | Successfully drag bunt for a base hit. | Silver
|
| Champs Get Degrees | Win the College Baseball Championship (RTTS) (excludes simulated gameplay). | Silver
|
| Didn't Even See It | Strike a batter out with a pitch of at least 101 mph. | Silver
|
| Easy as 1, 2, 3 | Throw a 3-pitch strikeout (excludes simulated gameplay). | Silver
|
| Entertain the People | Play in the Home Run Derby (Home Run Derby, RTTS, or Franchise). | Bronze
|
| Fan I Am | Use the Fan Cam to take a look around the stadium. | Bronze
|
| First of Many | Reach either of the following milestones in RTTS: First MLB Hit or First MLB Strikeout (excludes simulated gameplay). | Bronze
|
| Fundamental Baseball | Complete a game, of at least nine innings, without your team committing an error (excludes simulated gameplay). | Gold
|
| Going Pro | Get ten hits using ambush hitting. | Silver
|
| HOF Worthy | Get any player into the Hall of Fame (MTO, Franchise, or RTTS). | Gold
|
| Jack of All Settings | In the same game, successfully use each type of hitting interface to get at least one hit with each, and each type of pitching interface to get at least one strikeout with each. | Gold
|
| Left It All Out There | Thank you for playing MLB The Show and leaving it all out on the field. | Platinum
|
| NLB Historian '25 | Complete three Negro League Storylines. | Gold
|
| Needs Filled | Sign a Top 10 free agent from your Free Agency Big Board in MTO or Franchise. | Gold
|
| One Job | Steal a base with a pinch runner (excludes simulated gameplay). | Bronze
|
| Play My Way | Save any Custom Game Entry setting in Franchise. | Bronze
|
| Station to Station | In a single inning, score a run without getting an extra base hit or stealing any bases (excludes simulated gameplay). | Silver
|
| Staying Alive | As a batter, go from an 0-2 count to a 3-2 (full) count (excludes simulated gameplay). | Silver
|
| Take it Or Leave It | Sign a player with a last chance contract (March to October and Franchise). | Silver
|
| Why We Play | Win the World Series in MTO, Franchise, or RTTS (excludes simulated gameplay). | Silver
|
| Why are You Running? | As an outfielder, throw out a runner with a perfect throw, while the Button Accuracy setting is enabled. | Bronze
|
| Womp Womp | While on offense, end an inning with the bases loaded and no runs scored (excludes simulated gameplay). | Bronze
|