| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| Another Paper Weight! | In Mini Seasons, have a member of your team win any award. | Silver
|
| Back in My Day | Win a game within Retro Mode. | Bronze
|
| Back to Back Jacks! | Hit back to back home runs within any mode. (Excludes simulated gameplay) | Gold
|
| Baseball Beats to Play To | Within the jukebox menu, play a new song from the Jukebox. | Bronze
|
| Brand Deal | Equip two or more items of the same equipment brand on your Ballplayer or created player. | Bronze
|
| Champion of the Diamond! | Achieve all trophies in MLB The Show 23. | Platinum
|
| Designated Dinger | In any mode, hit a home run with your team's Designated Hitter. (Excludes simulated gameplay) | Silver
|
| Follow the Hype Train | Complete two or more Moments. | Silver
|
| Future of the Franchise | Draft a player in the amateur draft in Franchise or March to October. | Silver
|
| Guess What's Coming | In any game mode, strikeout a batter using only one type of pitch. (Must be a full at-bat. Excludes simulated gameplay, using Quick Counts, joining moments) | Silver
|
| Heart of the City | In any game mode, play a game with a City Connect uniform. | Silver
|
| Here comes the paint! | Acquire any diamond level Starting Pitcher card from a program reward or card pack. | Gold
|
| If You Love Something... | Sell a diamond rarity card on the community market, using the "Sell Now" option. | Bronze
|
| Job Security | Achieve both the Yearly and Contract goal for your GM within Franchise. | Silver
|
| Just Getting Started | In Diamond Dynasty, complete any program. | Bronze
|
| Lead the Way Cap | In Diamond Dynasty, unlock a captain's tier two ability within your squad builder. | Silver
|
| Looking Good! | Create your team's custom uniform in Diamond Dynasty. | Bronze
|
| Make The Dance | Make the POSTSEASON within March to October. | Gold
|
| NLB Historian | Complete all the Negro League Baseball storylines. | Gold
|
| Old School | In any game mode, have a closer pitch two innings for a save. (Excludes simulated gameplay or joining game moments in progress) | Silver
|
| Practice Makes Perfect | In custom practice, create a custom play. | Bronze
|
| Quick Turnaround | Achieve a five star offseason within March To October. | Gold
|
| This Day in History | Play a Topps Now Moment. | Silver
|
| This Hobby of Mine | In Diamond Dynasty, claim three collection rewards. | Bronze
|
| To the Moon! | Hit a HR with at least five seconds or more of hang time. (Excludes simulated gameplay) | Bronze
|
| Unparalleled Pro | In Diamond Dynasty, reach level 3 parallel on any player card. | Gold
|