| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| A Trip to the Coast | Enzo saved Isabella. | Bronze
|
| Bombas Away! | Killed ten enemies with explosives. | Bronze
|
| Bona Furtuna | Found a Trinacria coin. | Bronze
|
| Cold-Blooded | Performed thirty headshots. | Bronze
|
| Daredevil | Jumped a car over fourty meters. | Silver
|
| Driving in Style | Customized a car. | Bronze
|
| Everything you Deserve | Enzo killed the Spadaro holdouts. | Bronze
|
| Everything's Golden | Enzo won the race. | Bronze
|
| Fantasma | Infiltrated the villa without being seen. | Silver
|
| Fastest Man in Sicily | Completed the race in under eight minutes. | Bronze
|
| Forza San Celeste | Enzo won the Palio. | Bronze
|
| Full Steam Ahead | Beat the train. | Bronze
|
| Garden Rendezvous | Met Isabella in secret. | Bronze
|
| Getaway Driver | Drove at 120 km/h for at least fifteen seconds. | Silver
|
| Good as New | Fixed a broken vehicle by using the crank. | Bronze
|
| Guest of Honor | Enzo found a new home. | Bronze
|
| Lira for Lira | Enzo freed the counterfeiter. | Bronze
|
| Live by the Blade | erformed all Special Actions five times with each knife. | Bronze
|
| Man of Honor | Enzo refused Tino's order to kill in cold blood. | Silver
|
| Most Dutiful Soldier | Enzo exacted revenge. | Bronze
|
| Mystery Fox Domination | All Mystery Foxes found. | Silver
|
| Neutral Ground | Enzo lost his mentor. | Bronze
|
| No More Running | Enzo killed his nemesis. | Bronze
|
| Not So Fast | Killed Caccini before he reached the Salt Flats. | Silver
|
| Only One Way Out | Enzo and Isabella's story came to an end. | Bronze
|
| Protected | Equipped a Charm. | Bronze
|
| Rare Weapons Expert: Lupara | Killed twenty enemies with a Lupara. | Bronze
|
| Rare Weapons Expert: Modello | Killed twenty enemies with a Modello C96. | Bronze
|
| Rare Weapons Expert: Praecisione | Killed twenty enemies with a Praecisione. | Bronze
|
| Rare Weapons Expert: Pump-Action | Killed twenty enemies with a Pump-Action Shotgun. | Bronze
|
| Rare Weapons Expert: Repeater | Killed twenty enemies with a Repeater. | Bronze
|
| Rare Weapons Expert: Vendetti | Killed twenty enemies with a Vendetti. | Bronze
|
| Read All About It | Found a Newspaper. | Bronze
|
| Riding in Style | Customized a horse. | Bronze
|
| Salvatore's Apprentice | Cracked a safe without a combination. | Bronze
|
| Secret Assassin | Killed twenty enemies with Knife Takedowns. | Bronze
|
| Silent Hunter | Killed Mazzone without alerting his men. | Bronze
|
| The Carusu | Enzo escaped the mine. | Bronze
|
| The Collector | Completed the collection. | Gold
|
| The Don | Completed all Trophies. | Platinum
|
| The Family Business | Enzo learned the ropes. | Bronze
|
| The Finer Things | Bought all available cars from Pasquale. | Bronze
|
| The Old Country | Completed the story on any difficulty. | Silver
|
| The Old Ways | Reached the foreman's office without alerting the enemies. | Silver
|
| The Rat | Enzo and Cesare killed L'Ombra. | Bronze
|
| This Thing of Ours | Enzo got made. | Bronze
|
| Total Shutdown | Enzo found the foreman. | Bronze
|
| Trail of Destruction | Eliminated ten cars while escaping the Tonnara. | Silver
|
| True Soldato | Completed the story on Hard difficulty. | Gold
|
| Vulpi Misteriusa | Found a Mystery Fox. | Bronze
|
| Worthy Opponent | Defeated Don Torrisi without taking a single hit. | Silver
|