| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| Already in Progress | Create a league from a Play Now Live game. | Bronze
|
| Big Spender | Win a free agent bidding war for a 90+ OVR player. | Gold
|
| Bragging Rights | Win the Super Bowl in an online league. | Gold
|
| Change of Scenery | Relocate a team. | Bronze
|
| Clean The Pile | User Hit Stick the Pile or Standup Tackle resulting in a fumble. | Silver
|
| Dealmaker | Re-sign a 90+ OVR player. | Gold
|
| Future of the Franchise | Reveal a rookie's X-Factor potential. | Silver
|
| Gain Train | Reach max level with your Avatar in the RB Position. | Silver
|
| Head-to-Head | Win a Head To Head game in an online league. | Silver
|
| Lockdown Corner | Win three presses in a single game with the same CB. | Silver
|
| Lockdown Leader | Reach max level with your Avatar in the CB Position. | Silver
|
| MVP | Win MVP with one of your players. | Gold
|
| Madden NFL 23 Master | Congratulations on earning every Madden NFL 23 trophy! | Platinum
|
| Ol' Reliable | Reach max level with your Avatar in the WR Position. | Silver
|
| Pocket Ace | Reach max level with your Avatar in the QB Position. | Silver
|
| Primetime | Gain yards while using Celebration Loco over the course of a single game. | Silver
|
| Pro Bowler | Play in the Pro Bowl during a Franchise season. | Gold
|
| ROTY | Win Rookie of the Year with one of your players. | Gold
|
| Roster Reshuffle | Complete a fantasy draft. | Bronze
|
| Saw It Coming | User uses a Tendency Counter on a play that results in a turnover. | Bronze
|
| Stud Finder | Draft a rookie with a Hidden Dev Trait. | Bronze
|
| The Fortress | Reach max level with your Avatar in the LB Position. | Silver
|
| Throwin' Dots | Throw a Passing TD using the low throw mechanic. | Bronze
|
| Unblockable | On three plays create a sack or tackle for loss after a pass rush move win, using a different rush move each time. | Gold
|