| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| Bringer of Light | Reignite the lighthouse. | Bronze
|
| Cannibal | Cook a Follower meat meal. | Bronze
|
| Crosser of Thresholds | A new world awaits. | Bronze
|
| Cure | Beat Kallamar without taking damage. | Silver
|
| Curses of Plenty | Unlock all curses. | Silver
|
| Deal with the Devil | A deal that cannot be undone. | Bronze
|
| Death to Non-Believers | Defeat the first mini-boss. | Bronze
|
| Devotion | Fully Upgrade Cult. | Silver
|
| Do No Evil | Defeat the One Who Waits. | Gold
|
| First Follower | The first devotee to the Cult of the Lamb. | Bronze
|
| Flock of All | Gain twenty Followers. | Gold
|
| Flock of Many | Gain ten Followers. | Silver
|
| Full Deck | Unlock all tarot cards. | Silver
|
| Full Flock | Unlock all Follower Skins. | Silver
|
| Game of Chance | Win a game of Knucklebones. | Bronze
|
| Godhood | No longer a servant, no less than a God. | Platinum
|
| Gospel | Unlock all doctrines. | Silver
|
| Hear No Evil | Defeat Kallamar. | Silver
|
| Hoarder of Wealth | Have 666 gold coins. | Silver
|
| Keeper of Secrets | Take confession. | Bronze
|
| Leader of the Crusade | Find all five locations. | Silver
|
| Master of Chance | Defeat all opponents in Knucklebones. | Silver
|
| Order | Beat Leshy without taking damage. | Silver
|
| Peace | Beat Shamura without taking damage. | Silver
|
| Preacher of Truth | Let the Word be known. | Bronze
|
| Sacrificial Beast | Sacrifice a Follower. | Bronze
|
| Sate | Beat Heket without taking damage. | Silver
|
| See No Evil | Defeat Leshy. | Bronze
|
| Speak No Evil | Defeat Heket. | Bronze
|
| Teach a Lamb to Fish | Catch one of every fish. | Silver
|
| The First Death | Salvation awaits the fallen soul. | Bronze
|
| The Flock Grows | Gain five Followers. | Silver
|
| Think No Evil | Defeat Shamura. | Silver
|
| Transform | Unlock a new fleece. | Bronze
|
| Transmute | Unlock all fleeces. | Silver
|
| Weapons of Plenty | Unlock all weapons. | Silver
|
| Weigher of Souls | Sacrifice ten Followers. | Gold
|