| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| A New World | Dive underwater with the mermaid. | Gold
|
| Beating a Punching Bag | Observe as Cameron beats Larry... again. | Silver
|
| Blue Orb of Light | Follow the orb of light. | Gold
|
| Broken | Support Diana when she needs consoling. | Silver
|
| Closer Than Friends | Watch as Cameron is ready to go on a date. | Gold
|
| Existence | See Anya talk about her broken family. | Silver
|
| Fun Memories | Make silly faces with friends. | Silver
|
| Home Sweet Home | Pay respects with Elisabeth. | Gold
|
| Inside the Locker Room | Notice something... different about Cameron. | Silver
|
| Magical Transformation | Learn the mermaid's true identity. | Silver
|
| Merfolk Lovers | Witness the merfolk kiss after they reunite. | Gold
|
| Platinum Aquadine | Get all other trophies. | Platinum
|
| Playing in the Acqua Alta | Hang out with your friends in the acqua alta. | Bronze
|
| Returning to Stage | Support Elisabeth as she makes her comeback. | Gold
|
| The Beautiful Mermaid | Encounter the mermaid for the first time. | Bronze
|
| The Prize | Witness the moment when Ciel gives Diana her prize. | Gold
|
| Tomorrow is a New Day | Cherish the memories of your family and friends. | Gold
|
| Trauma | Learn about Elisabeth's past. | Silver
|
| True Calling | Watch Diana try on new clothes. | Gold
|