| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| BFF | Kill Lisa Horowitz. | Silver
|
| Blanket | Do not let Faye get cold. | Bronze
|
| Brotherhood | Complete the Pirate Brotherhood's secret handshake. | Silver
|
| Canyon | Throw Ed's car down the cliff. | Bronze
|
| Engine | Fix a car. | Bronze
|
| Feast | Feed Frankie Laine just like he deserves. | Silver
|
| Feed | Fill Petronius' bowl. | Bronze
|
| Figurines | Find all of Captain Roberts' spies. | Silver
|
| Five | Complete Ed's fifth therapy session. | Gold
|
| Flamingo | Say goodbye to a childhood friend. | Bronze
|
| Four | Complete Ed's fourth therapy session. | Gold
|
| Groceries | Get mom's congratulations for storing the groceries quickly. | Silver
|
| Gun | Find evidence against Ed Miller. | Bronze
|
| Hand | Get Ed to shake Julia's hand. | Bronze
|
| Host | Make sure Ed doesn't get thirsty. | Bronze
|
| Jenny | Confirm the existence of Ed's daughter. | Bronze
|
| MVP | Help Eddie Miller become the season's hero. | Bronze
|
| Melody | Listen to Faye's song all the way through. | Bronze
|
| One | Complete Ed's first therapy session. | Gold
|
| Orphan | Get rid of your father's influence. | Silver
|
| Pliers | Convince Adam to release you. | Silver
|
| Restaurant | Dine at Mamma Louise. | Silver
|
| Romance | Get Julia and Nick together. | Silver
|
| Sam | Find Samuel Franklin. | Bronze
|
| Scar | Take a seat. | Bronze
|
| Stone | Access one of Julia's childhood memories. | Bronze
|
| Support | Comfort Robert. | Bronze
|
| Thief | Get all trophies in the game. | Platinum
|
| Three | Complete Ed's third therapy session. | Gold
|
| Tree | Dive into Julia and Nick's past. | Bronze
|
| Two | Complete Ed's second therapy session. | Gold
|
| Vertigo | Overcome Vertigo by saving Esther Franklin and Jenny. | Gold
|