| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| ... And I Can Not Lie (secret) | Complete TBubber and Dunkin's game | Silver
|
| Epilogue (secret) | Survive the Epilogue | Silver
|
| Fifth Hour | Survive Hour Five | Silver
|
| First Hour | Survive Hour One | Bronze
|
| Fourth Hour | Survive Hour Four | Bronze
|
| Hidden in the Darkness (secret) | Unlock the secret game | Bronze
|
| Laid to Rest... (secret) | Deliver all 5 items | Bronze
|
| Last Year... | Find what is lost | Bronze
|
| Matchstick Man | Survive an hour with only using matches | Bronze
|
| No Way Out (secret) | Complete last year | Silver
|
| Reveal the Truth (secret) | Unlock the Epilogue | Silver
|
| Second Hour | Survive Hour Two | Bronze
|
| Sunday Worship | Go to church | Bronze
|
| Third Hour | Survive Hour Three | Bronze
|
| True Detective | Collect all evidence | Bronze
|
| We're Gonna Need A Bigger Fridge | Collect all drawings | Bronze
|