| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| Ahab's Prosthesis | Ahab is ready for the hunt. | Bronze
|
| Harpooned Whale | Ahab got what he wanted. | Gold
|
| No Big Guns | Beat the game without using SWAT. | Bronze
|
| No Bullshit | Don't bite on a single false alarm. | Bronze
|
| No God | Take advantage of all Special Church services. | Bronze
|
| No Irish | Beat the game without using the Paddy Wagon. | Bronze
|
| No One Left Behind | Respond to all legitimate/bona-fide calls. | Silver
|
| Severed Leg | Ahab lost his leg, but it only made him angrier. | Bronze
|
| Sinking Pequod | The ship fell victim to Ahab's obsession. | Gold
|
| Whaleboat on the Water | Ahab prepared for the decisive blow. | Bronze
|