| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| A Table of Tales | Completed All Trophies | Platinum
|
| Beardbiter's Fury (secret) | Get Captain Harrow's Axe from Fort Raspe | Silver
|
| Crab Chowder (secret) | Defeat Horatio and the giant crab he summoned. | Gold
|
| Damp Sorcery (secret) | Throw Nuna overboard | Bronze
|
| Dodge This! (secret) | Take out the Hidden Harbor's sniper. | Bronze
|
| Faster than Lightning (secret) | Almost capture the strange Assassin | Bronze
|
| Fire Fighter (secret) | Save the Emerald Post from burning down | Bronze
|
| Goblark Scourge (secret) | Save ALL the Villagers of Tidewreath from the Goblarks | Bronze
|
| Hammer's Sacrifice (secret) | Have Hammer save the day | Silver
|
| High Profile (secret) | Take the Sunfish ship | Bronze
|
| Horatio No-Lives (secret) | Throw Horatio overboard | Bronze
|
| Horatio's Sacrifice (secret) | Have Horatio save the day | Silver
|
| Independent Scoundrels (secret) | Defeat the Orcs without Starling's help | Bronze
|
| Light Flickers (secret) | Ensure Bestoja does not fall to the Shadows | Silver
|
| Low Key (secret) | Take the Sawtooth ship | Bronze
|
| Mad Science (secret) | Defeat Thomas and his strange coral clones. | Gold
|
| Not Quick Enough... (secret) | Hand Quick over to the Crown Authorities | Silver
|
| Nuna's Sacrifice (secret) | Have Nuna save the day | Silver
|
| One Must Remain (secret) | Defeat Nuna within the Thing Outside's dimension | Gold
|
| Shut the Door (secret) | Close the temple's summit portal to the Thing Outside | Silver
|
| Sinking Hammer (secret) | Throw Hammer overboard | Bronze
|
| The Governator (secret) | Defeat the Hammer and her strange Cyclops form. | Gold
|
| The Missing Rorqual (secret) | Let the strange coral overrun the Rorqual | Bronze
|
| The Quick and The Dead (secret) | Leave Quick to die on Diamond Island. | Bronze
|
| The Shadows Consume (secret) | The island of Bestoja is destroyed by the Thing Outside | Bronze
|
| The Shadows Hide (secret) | Get into the Temple without being seen | Bronze
|
| The Weevil Squirms (secret) | Get the information from Weevil without "accidentally" killing him | Silver
|
| Thomas' Sacrifice (secret) | Have Thomas save the day | Silver
|
| Watered Down Potion (secret) | Throw Thomas overboard | Bronze
|
| Wrench in the Machine (secret) | Disable the Rorqual and get away. | Silver
|
| Zainab's Compassion (secret) | Zainab unchains Horatio in their final fight with the Orcs. | Silver
|
| Zainab's Return (secret) | Ensure Zainab survives and returns to her village. | Silver
|
| Zainab's Sacrifice (secret) | Zainab is killed fighting Orcs on the ocean floor | Bronze
|