| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| Full Boat | Get a Full House in Showdown with Hold 'Em power ups. | Bronze
|
| Gunslinger | Get a combo for over $500 in Story mode on any difficulty. | Bronze
|
| Hats Off | Get six fatal headshots in six consecutive shots with a pistol in Story mode. | Bronze
|
| Historical Account | Complete the Journal. | Bronze
|
| Manny Quinn (secret) | Complete a chapter in Red Wood Revolver mode. | Bronze
|
| Out For Blood | Complete every chapter in Bounty Hunter mode. | Bronze
|
| Peashooter | Complete the game on Normal difficulty. | Bronze
|
| Quick On The Draw | Win a duel in Story mode. | Bronze
|
| Red Dead Eye | Complete a chapter with 100% accuracy. | Bronze
|
| Sharp Shooter | Complete the game on Very Hard difficulty. | Gold
|
| Six Shooter | Complete the game on Hard difficulty. | Silver
|
| Untouchable | Complete any chapter on Very Hard without taking damage. | Bronze
|
| Well Provisioned | Unlock all additional content available for purchase in the Shop. | Bronze
|