| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| Beatdown City | Mercy the CPU (doesn't work in Easy Mode) | Bronze
|
| Crank It Up | Win three 9-inning games on Hard (season mode only) | Bronze
|
| Finish Line | Win the World Series (Season Mode only) | Silver
|
| Golden Goose Egg | Pitch a complete game shutout on Hard with Standard fielding | Bronze
|
| Line 'Em Up | Strike out the side vs CPU, allowing no baserunners | Bronze
|
| R.B.I. Overlord | Hit 1000 RBIs (any mode) | Gold
|
| Slammin' | Hit a grand slam (any mode) | Bronze
|
| Team Effort | Pitch a no-hitter with 5 or more pitchers (excluding Easy mode) | Bronze
|
| Top Dog - Home Runs | Beat the 2016 HR leader: 48 Home Runs in a season with a single player | Silver
|
| Top Dog - Runs | Beat the 2016 RBI leader: 134 Runs in a season with a single player | Silver
|
| Top Dog - Strikeouts | Beat the 2016 Strikeouts leader: 285 Strikeouts in a season with a single player | Silver
|