| Trophy | How to unlock
|
|---|
| Aces All Around (Bronze) | Score 5 consecutive Wins with your starting pitchers (Season or Postseason Mode)
|
| Back-to-Back (Bronze) | Hit 2 consecutive Home runs (vs CPU or Online Ranked only)
|
| DH Debate (Bronze) | Hit a Home Run with the Pitcher (vs CPU or Online Ranked only)
|
| Double Digits (Bronze) | Score at least 10 runs and win in an Online Ranked game
|
| Eye on the Ball (Bronze) | Win a 9-inning game without striking out (vs CPU or Online Ranked only)
|
| Going the Distance (Bronze) | Win 12 Complete Games in a single Season (starting pitcher must go all 9 innings)
|
| Hot Streak (Bronze) | Win 20 games within any single month (Season Mode only - sim games don't count)
|
| Movin' On (Bronze) | Qualify for the Postseason in Season Mode (play at least 50% of total games)
|
| Not Today, Partner (Bronze) | Knock out the CPU's pitcher by the 3rd inning
|
| R.B.I. Machine (Silver) | Hit 1000 RBIs (any mode)
|
| Road Warrior (Bronze) | Win an Online Ranked match
|
| Save One For Me! (Bronze) | Score a save in 5 straight games with any pitchers (Season or Postseason Mode)
|
| Speedster (Bronze) | Steal 40 bases with a single player in Season mode
|
| Stayin' Alive (Bronze) | Reach base after an AB of 10 or more pitches (vs CPU or Online Ranked only)
|
| Top Dog - Home Runs (Bronze) | Beat the 2015 HR leader: 48 Home Runs in a season with a single player
|
| Top Dog - RBIs (Bronze) | Beat the 2015 RBI leader: 131 RBIs in a season with a single player
|
| Top Dog - Strikeouts (Bronze) | Beat the 2015 Strikeouts leader: 302 Strikeouts in a season with a single player
|
| Uncontainable (Bronze) | Score in every inning of a 9-inning game (vs CPU or Online Ranked only)
|
| World Champions (Silver) | Win the World Series (Season Mode only)
|