| Trophy | How to unlock
|
|---|
| Classic Win (Bronze) | Win a complete game in 16-man roster against the CPU (1 pitcher).
|
| Clean Sweep (Bronze) | Sweep the post season (either mode).
|
| Couch Play (Bronze) | Play a local multiplayer game.
|
| Grand Tour (Bronze) | Play a game in all 30 stadiums.
|
| Home Run Flurry (Bronze) | Hit 3 Home Runs in a single inning in an Online Ranked game.
|
| In Your Crawl Space (Bronze) | Mercy an opponent in online ranked mode.
|
| Midsummer Classic (Bronze) | Win the All-Star game in Season Mode.
|
| Online Ownage (Bronze) | Win 50 Online Multiplayer Games.
|
| Plunked (Bronze) | Hit a batter with a pitch.
|
| Punchout (Bronze) | Strike out the CPU.
|
| R.B.I. Master (Silver) | Hit 1,000 RBIs.
|
| R.B.I. Skills (Bronze) | Hit 50 RBIs with the same player in Season Mode.
|
| Salami (Bronze) | Hit a Grand Slam (Against CPU or Online Ranked Only).
|
| Speed Merchant (Bronze) | Steal 25 Bases in online ranked mode.
|
| Take A Seat (Bronze) | Strike out the side against the CPU.
|
| Tater Time (Bronze) | Hit a home run (Against CPU or Online Ranked Only).
|
| Thievery (Bronze) | Steal a Base (Against CPU or Online Ranked Only).
|
| Walk Off (Bronze) | Hit a walk-off home run (Against CPU or Online Ranked Only).
|
| World Champs (Silver) | Win the World Series.
|