| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| Blow'em Out | Win by a goal difference of 5 goals in the Story Game: "" | Silver
|
| Brick Wall | Unlock the "Lou Petit" collectible by completing the Shut Out objective in Story Mode | Gold
|
| Bush League Trick | Unlock the "Rex 'Goldie' Talon" collectible by completing the objective in Story Mode | Silver
|
| Collateral Damage | Hip Check a teammate along with an opponent | Bronze
|
| Complete Set | Get all the Collectibles in the Game | Gold
|
| Crusin For A Boozin | Hit Cliff Parnassus in the Story Game: "Cruisin for a Boozin" | Silver
|
| Enforcer | Unlock the "Terry Peace" collectible by completing the PIMs objective in Story Mode | Silver
|
| Eye For An Eye | Injure Jim 'The Crook' Shepherd in the Story Game: "" | Silver
|
| Faceoff Expert | Unlock the "Roy Sterling" collectible by completing the Faceoff objective in Story Mode | Bronze
|
| Hattrick | Unlock the "Barry Walters" collectible by completing the objective in Story Mode | Silver
|
| He Shoots, He Scores | Unlock the "Jack Goff" collectible by completing the Deke and Score objective in Story Mode | Bronze
|
| Ice To Meet You | Win the Line Brawl in the Story Game: "" | Silver
|
| Penalty Killer | Unlock the "Gump Monahan" collectible by completing the Kill Penalties objective in Story Mode | Silver
|
| Pumped Up! | Max out all Progression Stars before entering Playoffs in a Story Mode Season | Gold
|
| Real Old-Fashioned Guts | Win enough fights in one game to have atleast 10 opposing players fatigued | Silver
|
| Real Puckhead | Finish one Story Mode Plus Season on any Difficulty | Gold
|
| Scarifice The Body | Unlock the "Toe O'Sullivan" collectible by completing the Block Shots objective in Story Mode | Silver
|
| Silence On The Ice | Win the Bench Brawl in the Story Game: "" | Silver
|
| Soft Sieve | Instigate Guy Beaulieu in the Story Game: "" | Silver
|
| Sticky Situation | Unlock the "Barney Williams" collectible by completing the Stick Fight objective in Story Mode | Gold
|
| Teamwork | In a local co-op game, score a goal while your teammate is instigating the Goaltender | Bronze
|
| True Hockey Fan | Unlock all the trophies in Old Time Hockey! | Platinum
|
| We Are The Champions! | Finish Story Mode on any Difficulty | Gold
|