| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| A Captivating Matter (secret) | Get to the prison cell. | Silver
|
| About That Pact (secret) | Find out how to cancel the pact. | Silver
|
| Animal Lover | Interact with 3 Animals on the Island. | Bronze
|
| Bewitching Hour (secret) | Get the witch to help you. | Silver
|
| Card Collector | Find all of the Pirate Cards. | Silver
|
| Completist | Complete the game. | Gold
|
| Every Last One | Finish all Hidden Object Puzzles without using hints. | Gold
|
| Expert Player | Complete the game on expert difficulty. | Gold
|
| Hidden Talent | Finish any Hidden Object scene with less than 4 mistakes. | Bronze
|
| His Secrets (secret) | Find out what Davy Jones is hiding in the Icehouse. | Silver
|
| Lost Memories (secret) | Listen to all of the Guardians’ stories. | Silver
|
| Marksman | Finish any Hidden Object Puzzle in less than 1 minute. | Bronze
|
| Naturist | Interact with 16 Animals on the Island. | Silver
|
| No Man Treads (secret) | Open the Forbidden Gate. | Silver
|
| No Skipping! | Finish all Puzzles without using the Skip Button. | Gold
|
| O’Malley (secret) | Get to ’s Hideout. | Silver
|
| On a Roll! | Finish 6 Hidden Object Puzzles in a row without using hints. | Silver
|
| Platinum | Unlock every Trophy. | Platinum
|
| Puzzling Find | Find the first hidden puzzle piece. | Bronze
|
| Quick Sleuth | Find 5 hidden objects within 5 seconds. | Bronze
|
| Scullion's Tale (secret) | Reconnect with Cory. | Silver
|
| Seahorse Ashore | Find a glowing seahorse. | Bronze
|
| Special Card | Find the first Pirate Card. | Bronze
|
| The Alchemist (secret) | Brew O’Malley's potion. | Silver
|
| The Deal Is Off (secret) | Cancel all of the pacts. | Silver
|
| The Golden Hint (secret) | Find the hint about the treasure of Davy Jones. | Silver
|
| The Great Escape (secret) | Escape from the cell. | Silver
|
| The Joy of Mahjong | Finish 3 Hidden Object Puzzles by playing Mahjong. | Bronze
|
| The King’s Seahorses | Find all the glowing seahorses. | Silver
|
| There's a Skip Button? | Complete 3 Puzzles without using the Skip Button. | Silver
|
| Whole Picture | Find all of the hidden puzzle pieces. | Silver
|