| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| A Chip Off The Ol' Block (secret) | Hit a home run from both sides as a switch hitter. | Gold
|
| Big Fly Ohtani Son | Hit a home run with Ohtani on All-Star or above difficulty. | Silver
|
| Do It Like This | Equip an unlockable no doubt home run animation. | Bronze
|
| Father Son Picnic | Win the Home Run Derby® with Bryce Harper. | Silver
|
| G.O.A.T. | Earn all of The Show™ 19 Trophies. | Platinum
|
| Hello, World | In Road to the Show, complete the new player creation. | Bronze
|
| Hi, Dee | Have your first encounter with Heidi Watney. | Silver
|
| Immaculate Inning (secret) | 3 strikeouts, 9 pitches total in 1 inning. | Gold
|
| Lock Him Up | In Franchise mode, extend a player contract during the season. | Silver
|
| No-No (secret) | Throw a no hitter or perfect game in a 9 inning game. | Gold
|
| None Shall Pass (secret) | In Road to the Show, fail a challenge. | Bronze
|
| Patience Is A Virtue (secret) | Finish a game without skipping a presentation. | Gold
|
| Pump It | In Road to the Show, reach 10 reps in the bench press mini-game. | Bronze
|
| Simon Says | In Road to the Show, reach a score of 40 in the pitch memory mini-game. | Silver
|
| Some Like It Holt (secret) | Hit for a cycle in the Postseason™. | Gold
|
| Something To Talk About | In Diamond Dynasty, equip any unlocked audio. | Bronze
|
| The More You Know | In Diamond Dynasty, complete the onboarding tutorial. | Bronze
|
| Velociraptor | Hit the ball over 115+ mph. | Silver
|
| Walk This Way | Record a walk in your first at-bat of the game. | Bronze
|
| Welcome To The Chip (secret) | In Diamond Dynasty, reach the Championship Series Division in Ranked Seasons. | Gold
|
| Well That Was Easy (secret) | In Play Now, Retro Mode, or Franchise Mode, record 3 outs on 3 pitches in 1 inning by 1 pitcher. | Gold
|
| You're Not The Boss of Me | In Road to the Show successfully win a Boss Battle. | Silver
|
| Yyyaarrrrgghh! (secret) | In Road to the Show, create a player who was born "At Sea". | Bronze
|