| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| #1 Fan | In Road To The Show, get praise from your pitching coach on your first win as a MLB® pitcher. | Silver
|
| And Now A Word From Our Sponsor | Equip any sponsorship in Franchise mode. | Bronze
|
| Back In My Day... | Complete a full 9-inning game using two Legends teams without fast forwarding. | Bronze
|
| Can I Have That Back? | While in Road To The Show, participate in a post game interview after your first MLB® home run. | Silver
|
| Deal With It | Hit a grand slam. | Gold
|
| Dirty Jersey | Make a diving catch for an out. | Silver
|
| El Ciclo | Hit a single, double, triple and a home run with one player in a single game. | Gold
|
| Flawless Victory | Win a 9-inning game without committing any errors. | Gold
|
| G.O.A.T. | Earn all of The Show™ 18 Trophies. | Platinum
|
| Git Gud | With Pitch Feedback option ON, obtain "Good" pitch timing with the Pulse, Meter, or Pure Analog pitching interface. | Bronze
|
| Goodbye, Old Friend | While batting, accidentally break your bat. | Silver
|
| Hello, Is This Thing On? | While in Road To The Show, on a AA team, participate in a post game interview after being named the Player Of The Game. | Bronze
|
| Help Me Help You | Sign with an agent in Road To The Show. | Bronze
|
| I'm Not Gonna Cry | In Road To The Show, get called up to the MLB® while in the managers office. | Silver
|
| It's All In The Hips | Create or edit a batting stance in the new editor. | Bronze
|
| Jury Duty | Accidentally give up a home run to Aaron Judge. | Silver
|
| No Pressure Kid | Draft a prospect in the First-Year Player Draft in Franchise mode. | Bronze
|
| No Sweat | In a half inning, strikeout 3 batters in a row. | Gold
|
| No Take Backs | Manually make a trade with any team in Franchise mode. | Bronze
|
| Oh Hi Mark | Discover the newest member to join the MLB® The Show™ 18 broadcast booth. | Bronze
|
| Old School Cool | Complete a Retro mode game in Franchise without fast forwarding. | Bronze
|
| Respek | While batting, reach base on an intentional walk. | Bronze
|
| Small Ball | While batting, perform a sacrifice bunt to advance a baserunner safely. | Silver
|
| Souvenir City | Hit 5 or more total home runs with one team in a single game. | Gold
|
| Talking About Practice | Create a custom play in practice mode. | Bronze
|
| Thanks For Sharing | Download any item from the Vault. | Bronze
|
| Three Bagger | Hit a triple. | Silver
|
| When It Rains, It Pours | Obtain 10 or more hits in a single game. | Gold
|
| Who's Eating Tuna? | In Road To The Show, while in the MLB®, fly in a plane to your next game. | Bronze
|