| Trophy | How to unlock
|
|---|
| A Bit Closer to Heaven (Silver) | Complete Part III on any difficulty.
|
| A Cold Day in Hell (Bronze) | Complete Part II on any difficulty.
|
| Feel the Payne (Silver) | Complete the game in Hard-Boiled mode.
|
| Four for the Price of One (Bronze) | Kill four enemies with one thrown grenade.
|
| Plenty to Go Around (Bronze) | Snipe 10 consecutive enemies without missing a shot.
|
| Quickest on the Draw (Silver) | Kill 10 enemies during one use of Bullet Time.
|
| The American Dream (Bronze) | Complete Part I on any difficulty.
|
| The Last Challenge (Gold) | Complete the End Combat.
|
| Trick Shot (Bronze) | Kill two enemies during one Shoot Dodge.
|
| Under Par (Silver) | Finish the game quicker than the Remedy par time in New York Minute mode.
|
| Weapons Training (Bronze) | Locate the Secret Room during the Tutorial.
|