| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| 2nd Rounder | Make game-winning FG under 10 sec. after missing 2 or more previous kick attempts. | Silver
|
| 7 on 7 | Finish the game. | Bronze
|
| Aaron Donald Legacy Award | Using a created player, coach, or owner - surpass a legacy score of 1,800. | Bronze
|
| Aaron Rodgers Legacy Award | Using a created player, coach, or owner - surpass a legacy score of 8,300. | Bronze
|
| All the Marbles | Finish the Week 12 game. | Silver
|
| Alvin Kamara Legacy Award | Using a created player, coach, or owner - surpass a legacy score of 750. | Bronze
|
| Antonio Brown Legacy Award | Using a created player, coach, or owner - surpass a legacy score of 2,750. | Bronze
|
| Audibilizing | Learn to Audible. | Bronze
|
| Beat the Bearcats | Beat the Beeville Bearcats. | Bronze
|
| Beat The Brush Hogs | Beat the Bloomington Brush Hogs. | Bronze
|
| Beat the Rattlers | Beat the Rancho Banquete Rattlers. | Bronze
|
| Beat the Skeeters | Beat the Skidmore Skeeters. | Bronze
|
| Colt's Grade | Finish the story with a grade of 80 or higher in Randy's fansite for Devin. | Silver
|
| Comeback City | Comeback and win when trailing by 17+ points at halftime. | Silver
|
| Devin's Grade | Finish the story with a grade of 80 or higher in Randy's fansite for Colt. | Silver
|
| Face the Dolphins | Finish the game against the Dolphins. | Bronze
|
| Full Set | Win a game with each of the 32 NFL teams - wins count across all game modes. | Gold
|
| Going For Gold | Earn gold from a drill inside the Skill Trainer. | Gold
|
| Grindin' Solos | Win a MUT Solo Challenge. | Bronze
|
| It's only the Preseason | Finish the Preseason Week Four Game. | Bronze
|
| Jerry Jones Legacy Award | Using a created player, coach, or owner - surpass a legacy score of 12,500. | Silver
|
| John Madden Legacy Award | Using a created player, coach, or owner - surpass a legacy score of 10,000. | Silver
|
| Living in the Past | Finish the Flashback game. | Bronze
|
| Lockdown Corner | Win 3 presses in a single game with the same CB. | Bronze
|
| Madden NFL 19 Master | Congratulations on earning every Madden NFL 19 trophy! | Platinum
|
| Move Master | Successfully fake-out a defender when prompted to perform a ball carrier special move. | Bronze
|
| Negotiator | Win a MUT auction. | Bronze
|
| Not OP | Successfully use the swat mechanic to force an incomplete pass. | Silver
|
| Return to Sender | Return the punt for a touchdown in the State Championship high school game. | Silver
|
| Richard Sherman Legacy Award | Using a created player, coach, or owner - surpass a legacy score of 7,000. | Bronze
|
| Situational Awareness | Make a Coaching Adjustment in the 4th quarter or OT. | Silver
|
| Step Up | Finish the Week 10 Game. | Bronze
|
| Team Building 101 | Activate two Chemistries at the same time. | Silver
|
| This is My Ultimate Team | Create a MUT Team. | Bronze
|
| Throwin’ Dots | Throw a Passing TD using the low throw mechanic. | Bronze
|
| Todd Gurley Legacy Award | Using a created player, coach, or owner - surpass a legacy score of 2,200. | Bronze
|
| Tom Brady Legacy Award | Using a created player, coach, or owner - surpass a legacy score of 27,000. | Gold
|
| Triple Crown | Record a sack, a forced fumble, and a fumble recovery with the same player on a single play. | Silver
|
| Von Miller Legacy Award | Using a created player, coach, or owner - surpass a legacy score of 3,100. | Bronze
|