| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| Ace in the Hole (secret) | Felicity convinces Judge Vanstone to release Finn | Bronze
|
| Antitrust (secret) | Finn teams up with Adam | Silver
|
| Bad Blood (secret) | Becky uncovers Adam's backstory | Bronze
|
| Blue Movies (secret) | Becky finds the spycam | Silver
|
| Bomb Squad (secret) | Becky defuses a bomb | Bronze
|
| Busted | Unanimously identify who has the Hidden Agenda | Bronze
|
| Butter Fingers (secret) | Vernon LeMay falls to his death | Bronze
|
| Case Closed (secret) | The Trapper is arrested | Silver
|
| Chinatown (secret) | The investigation hits a deadend | Bronze
|
| Choose Wisely | Make your first choice | Bronze
|
| CSI | Find every clue in a single search | Bronze
|
| Dead or Alive (secret) | The Trapper dies | Silver
|
| Deception | Win a Hidden Agenda | Bronze
|
| Double Jeopardy (secret) | Takeover a takeover | Bronze
|
| Dressed to Kill (secret) | Becky links the hooker to two previous murders | Silver
|
| Echoes (secret) | Daniella Cárdenas identifies the Trapper | Silver
|
| Fastest Finger | Succeed on a Quick Time Event | Bronze
|
| Fourth Degree (secret) | Felicity burns to death | Silver
|
| Fugitive (secret) | Finn escapes from police custody | Silver
|
| Goodbye World (secret) | The Trapper tries to commit suicide | Silver
|
| Gross Misconduct (secret) | Becky murders her sergeant | Silver
|
| Gun Shy | Complete the game without ever using a weapon | Silver
|
| Mastermind | Complete an Endgame Agenda | Silver
|
| Mercy Kill (secret) | Becky shoots Judge Vanstone | Bronze
|
| Mickey Finn (secret) | Becky is drugged | Bronze
|
| Movie Night | Complete Story Mode | Gold
|
| Night Moves (secret) | Felicity breaks into Simon's residence | Silver
|
| No Dice | Foil a Hidden Agenda | Bronze
|
| Open and Shut | Unanimously agree on a Trust question | Bronze
|
| Partners in Crime (secret) | Becky's partner helps her escape the cops | Silver
|
| Peacemaker | Don't shoot during a combat event | Bronze
|
| Platinum | Earn all other trophies | Platinum
|
| Rat in the Trap (secret) | Felicity tricks the killer into an ambush | Silver
|
| Red Wire, Blue Wire (secret) | Becky dies in an explosion | Bronze
|
| Sins of the Father (secret) | Becky finds Father Rominski's "Play Room" | Bronze
|
| Stalker (secret) | Becky catches a prowler in the cabin | Bronze
|
| The F Bomb (secret) | Becky swears at her partner | Bronze
|
| The Killer Unmasked (secret) | Simon is revealed as the Trapper | Silver
|
| The Rivals | Complete Competitive Mode | Gold
|
| Trust (secret) | Finn leads Becky to Adam | Silver
|
| Truth Hurts (secret) | Becky tells Finn about Calvary's murder | Bronze
|
| Wipeout (secret) | Becky and Felicity both die | Silver
|