| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| All The Dads | Earn every Dream Daddy trophy. | Platinum
|
| Asiago-getter | Go on all Hugo dates. | Silver
|
| Bad Dad | Slept with Robert on the first night. | Silver
|
| Cannonball | Jump off the waterfall too many times and bleed out. | Gold
|
| Catch of the day | Earn a match fishing score of 2000 | Gold
|
| Dreamiest Daddy | Go on every date with every dad. | Gold
|
| Interview With the Vampire | Go on all Damien dates. | Silver
|
| Keg-Stand Champion | Go on all Craig dates. | Silver
|
| King of Carrot Flowers | Go on all Mat dates. | Silver
|
| Knife Dad | Go on all Robert dates. | Silver
|
| Let Amanda Say [CENSORED] | Give Amanda permission to swear. | Silver
|
| Margarita Zone | Go on all Joseph dates. | Silver
|
| Panic! at the Disco | Attempt unrehearsed backflip. It does not go well. | Silver
|
| Save Ferris | Fall to your death all due to the folly of pride. | Gold
|
| Soft Boy | Go on all Brian dates. | Silver
|
| Welcome to the Neighborhood! | Successfully complete chapter one. | Silver
|
| World's Best Dad | Get good Amanda ending. | Gold
|
| World's Okayest Dad | Get bad Amanda ending. | Gold
|
| Yo Ho Ho Ho | Earn 18 hole-in-ones at pirate mini golf. | Gold
|