| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| All Star | Be drafted to play in an game in Career Mode. | Gold
|
| Back To Back | Win back to back matches in career mode. | Silver
|
| Best Of Both Worlds | Have your character win Pro Champ as Player and Coach. | Gold
|
| Coaching Immortal | Win 5 Championships (College or Pro). | Gold
|
| Difficult Customer | Win a game on All-American Difficulty. | Bronze
|
| Disciplined | Complete a match without giving away a penalty. | Gold
|
| Double Crosse | Score a goal after faking out the Goalie. | Bronze
|
| Faceoff Master | Cleanly win 3 faceoffs in a match. | Bronze
|
| Finals Bound | Reach a Final Series. | Bronze
|
| Hall of Fame | Collect all Trophies. | Platinum
|
| Hat Trick | Score three goals in a match with 1 player. | Bronze
|
| I Object | Complete all Objectives in a match. | Silver
|
| Keeper | Prevent opposition from scoring in a match. | Bronze
|
| Linked | Score a goal after linking 20 passes in attacking half. | Silver
|
| Longshot | Score a goal from over 25 yards. | Bronze
|
| MVP | Be of a match 5 times. | Gold
|
| Nailbiter | Score to win a match in the final minute of game time. | Gold
|
| New Entrant | Create a player in the academy. | Bronze
|
| On The Line | Complete 5 online matches | Silver
|
| Pass Around | Complete 500 passes in any game mode. | Silver
|
| Selected | Be drafted for a Pro League Team. | Silver
|
| Sharing Is Caring | Create and share a Team in the Academy. | Bronze
|
| Stadium Builder | Create a stadium using the stadium creator. | Silver
|
| Take A Dive | Score 25 Diving Shots. | Silver
|
| Traveler | Win a Match at every Stadium. | Bronze
|
| Unbeatable | Go through a season undefeated. | Gold
|
| We're Coming Back | Win a match after being behind by 3 goals. | Silver
|