| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| Baby Boom | Unlock all babies. | Gold
|
| Babysitters' Club | Successfully babysit with 4 sitters. | Gold
|
| Bad Bread (secret) | Successfully babysit Bread on Hard difficulty. | Gold
|
| Can't Touch This | Successfully babysit without the baby ever having gotten grabbed by an abductor. | Gold
|
| Certified Babysitter | Successfully babysit for the first time. | Gold
|
| Guardian of Babies | Unlock all trophies - because you're the best babysitter in the world! | Platinum
|
| Handful of Babies | Successfully babysit 4 babies in one sitting. | Gold
|
| In The Nick of Time (secret) | Have a baby return home after being dropped by an abductor just outside a doorway. | Gold
|
| The Efficient Sitter | Successfully babysit without ever having exhausted your hand. | Gold
|
| The Negligent Sitter (secret) | Successfully babysit while having had the baby grabbed by every type of abductor. | Gold
|
| The Proficient Sitter | Successfully babysit without ever having to retry. | Silver
|
| Veteran Babysitter | Successfully babysit on Hard difficulty for the first time. | Gold
|