| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| ...Bearded Travelers (secret) | The absurdity of underwater speech only adds to the wonder apparent on his face. | Gold
|
| A Bargain to Make (secret) | "Right, then. Let’s be off!" commands Brave Beard, striking a leaderly pose. | Gold
|
| Begone! (secret) | The men push off, paddling the raft beyond the island and into the night. | Gold
|
| Complimentary Trip to the Afterlife (secret) | "Shouldn’t you be a bit more chipper, having won and all?" prods Steady Beard. | Silver
|
| Foiled by the Tree (secret) | The jaws snap shut over the shattered tree, launching the men out into the deepening darkness. | Silver
|
| Fountain of the Faithless (secret) | "Give me water, and I’ll teach it to carry me!" | Bronze
|
| Getting Your Beards Wet (secret) | The orbs lead on, out through the cavern’s deep tunnels and beyond the island. | Silver
|
| Great Barnacled One (secret) | It’s dark inside the whale, but the men appear to be intact. | Bronze
|
| In Need of Assistance (secret) | Heedless of the warning, the burly seals spread out as they swim, until the spell around them weakens and they become human once more. | Silver
|
| Into the Deepening Darkness (secret) | The men paddle furiously, but the widening vortex is inescapable. | Silver
|
| Nice Day (secret) | Surfacing, they find themselves men once more, who, for the moment, splash about like happy children under the moonlit sky. | Gold
|
| Out of the Deepening Darkness (secret) | Collapsing, the maelstrom tosses the men in their barrels toward the surface. | Silver
|
| Poor Beastie (secret) | With a piercing screech, the creature disappears back into the depths. | Silver
|
| QUITE GOOD AT FLOWERS (secret) | "Quick, while we’ve a chance!" whispers Hasty Beard, leading the way to the boat. | Silver
|
| QUITE GOOD AT THROWING (secret) | "Great idea!" cuts in Steady Beard. "How about a demonstration?" | Silver
|
| She's a Goner (secret) | Clinging to wooden barrels, they watch their beloved ship sink into the depths. | Silver
|
| The Back Door (secret) | Following the glow of moonlight, the men step out eagerly into the night. | Silver
|
| The Long Way (secret) | "Really very sorry for scuttling your promotion and all that," offers Steady Beard. | Silver
|
| The Path of Waiting (secret) | "Time flows quickly in contemplation of the Great One’s splendor." | Bronze
|
| Thus is Thy Fate Sealed (secret) | With a rumble, the island sinks slowly into the sea, carrying all hands with it. | Gold
|
| Vengeance Satisfied (secret) | The creature drags the struggling men deeper beneath the waves, finally tossing them aside in disgust. | Silver
|
| Well Met... (secret) | "Er, hullo," stammers Brave Beard. | Gold
|
| Womenfolk in the Water (secret) | Finding the dark water empty, the men quickly regret their course of action. | Silver
|
| Wooden Trousers (secret) | "Aye, they’ll float," nods Steady Beard. | Bronze
|
| Ye've Done It | "This day, you reach the end of a story," she continues, "and the last of its paths." | Platinum
|