| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| A Chair in a Room | Complete the epilogue | Gold
|
| A development | Complete the dark room | Bronze
|
| A memory | Initiated the first memory | Bronze
|
| An apple from the tree | Get the preacher to confess | Bronze
|
| Arrested | There was never a trial | Bronze
|
| Feeder | Feed the crocodile | Silver
|
| Matthew 14:25 | He walked on water | Bronze
|
| Routine | Completed a day in the hospital | Bronze
|
| Signs of recognition | Cognitive response detected | Bronze
|
| Suppository | Give the preacher something he doesn't want. | Silver
|
| Tablets and ghosts | Consumed 66 tablets in the Pelican Motel | Silver
|
| What lies beneath? | Uncovered the body | Bronze
|