| Trophy | How to unlock
|
|---|
| Battering Ram (Bronze) | Defeated 'The Bullish Man'.
|
| Brought to you by,.... (Bronze) | Watch the credits without skipping.
|
| Carla Song (Silver) | Freed Carla from the trap.
|
| Compassion (Bronze) | Saved a person that you didn't have to.
|
| Did I fire 6 shots or only 5... (Bronze) | Joseph died.
|
| Firefighter (Bronze) | Barry died.
|
| Hands off (Bronze) | Zeke died.
|
| Hedgehog's Dilemma (Bronze) | Donovan died.
|
| Henry Jacobs (Silver) | Freed Henry from the trap.
|
| It must be SAW (Bronze) | Played on Halloween.
|
| Joseph Poltzer (Silver) | Freed Joseph from the trap.
|
| Now THAT'S using your head! (Bronze) | Escaped 'The Bullish Man'.
|
| Old School (Bronze) | Entered the legendary Konami Code.
|
| Path of Blood (Gold) | Campbell survived his test.
|
| Path of Flesh (Bronze) | Campbell did not survive his test.
|
| Sarah Blalock (Silver) | Freed Sarah from the trap.
|
| Solomon Bates (Silver) | Freed Solomon from the trap.
|
| Third time's the charm (Bronze) | Subdued the 'Bullish Man'.
|
| Would you like to play a game? (Bronze) | Completed the Eye Surgery Minigame.
|
| You wasted your life (Bronze) | Played on Christmas.
|
| Trophy | How to unlock
|
|---|
| A Little Background (Bronze) | Found your first Case file.
|
| Burned Out (Bronze) | Beat the best time for the Lights Out Minigame (Insane).
|
| Chromatic (Bronze) | Beat the best time for the Kaleidoscope Minigame (Normal).
|
| Congratulations (Platinum) | Acquired all trophies.
|
| Connect the dots... (Bronze) | Beat the best time for the Lights Out Minigame (Normal).
|
| Easy Listening (Bronze) | Found 1/2 of the Audio Tapes.
|
| Electrician (Bronze) | Beat the best time for the Polarized Circuit Minigame (Normal).
|
| Forced Perspective (Bronze) | Beat the best time for the Dial Puzzle Minigame (Insane).
|
| Gear Grinder (Bronze) | Beat the best time for the Jigsaw Box Minigame (Normal).
|
| Half the story (Bronze) | Found 1/2 of the Case Files.
|
| Journalist (Silver) | Found all 50 Case Files.
|
| Jury Rig (Bronze) | Beat the best time for the Polarized Circuit Minigame (Insane).
|
| Master Thief (Bronze) | Beat the best time for the Lockpick Minigame (Insane).
|
| Mechanic (Bronze) | Beat the best time for the Jigsaw Box Minigame (Insane).
|
| Mix Tape (Bronze) | Found 1/4 of the Audio Tapes.
|
| P2P (Bronze) | Beat the best time for the Point to Point Minigame (Insane).
|
| Paper-Mache (Bronze) | Found your first Billy Puppet.
|
| Play ME! (Bronze) | Found your first Audio Tape.
|
| Puppeteer (Silver) | Found all 7 Billy Puppets.
|
| Putting it all together (Silver) | Found all 25 puzzle pieces.
|
| Puzzle of Flesh (Bronze) | Found 1/4 of the puzzle pieces.
|
| Reel to Real (Silver) | Found all 20 Audio Tapes.
|
| Router (Bronze) | Beat the best time for the Point to Point Minigame (Normal).
|
| Running like Clockwork (Bronze) | Beat the best time for the Weapon Case Minigame (Normal).
|
| Second Amendment (Bronze) | Beat the best time for the Weapon Case Minigame (Insane).
|
| Smooth Criminal (Bronze) | Beat the best time for the Lockpick Minigame (Normal).
|
| Some light reading (Bronze) | Found 1/4 of the Case Files.
|
| Start with the Corners (Bronze) | Found your first puzzle piece.
|
| Starting to come together (Bronze) | Found 1/2 of the puzzle pieces.
|
| Thinking Three Steps Ahead (Bronze) | Beat the best time for the Kaleidoscope Minigame (Insane).
|
| Tumbler (Bronze) | Beat the best time for the Dial Puzzle Minigame (Normal).
|