| Trophy | How to unlock
|
|---|
| 'Checking Out.' (Bronze) | Overcame your fear of Scoggin' hidden people and stay on the case.
|
| 'The Cold Will Creep Right Up On Ya.' (Bronze) | Talked to Scruffman after seeing the unseeable outside of the diner.
|
| 'Yeah, I'm into some stuff.' (Bronze) | Helped Steve with his shipping problems.
|
| Crossword Double Cross (Bronze) | Thwarted Sheriff Bahg.
|
| Fidelity, Bravery, Integrity and Madness (Silver) | Completed the case and saw into the maw of madness.
|
| Hot Dish (Bronze) | Check into Valda's Inn
|
| Hvor er Olav Welhavven? (Bronze) | Took a transdimensional space voyage.
|
| Kicked the Habit (Silver) | Completed the case without chewing a piece of gum.
|
| Perfect Puzzle Agent (Gold) | Agent, you never submitted a wrong answer.
|
| The Professional (Silver) | Closed the case with the rank of 'Puzzle Agent.'
|
| Thorough Investigation (Silver) | Complete every puzzle in Scoggins.
|
| Your Tax Dollars at Work (Bronze) | Submitted a successful puzzle answer on the first try while in the field.
|