| Trophy | How to unlock
|
|---|
| Everyone's a Winner (Bronze) | Get a negative distance on the Anvil Toss in PAINalympics.
|
| Handy-capped (Silver) | Complete Mad Science! PAINFUL without grabbing.
|
| It's Full of Cars (Bronze) | Send the black sedan through the portal in PROBE.
|
| Lo Touch (Bronze) | Grab teleporting Hung Lo in PAIN Reunion.
|
| Secret Santa (Silver) | Open all the unlocked lockers in PAIN Reunion using Santa.
|
| Sore Spotting (Gold) | Find and hit the alien artifact in both PAIN Reunion and Sports Day and the Sports trophy in both PROBE and Afterglow.
|