| Trophy | How to unlock
|
|---|
| "King" Felix Hernandez (Gold) | In any game mode with Felix Hernandez, allow no earned runs and strike out 9 while earning the win.
|
| Back-To-Back (Bronze) | Hit back-to-back HRs in a game (excludes HRD, Practice, and RTTS modes).
|
| Breaking the Ice (Bronze) | Successfully create a Community Challenge.
|
| Chris "Crush" Davis (Silver) | In any game mode with Chris Davis, have a 2 home run, 5 RBI performance in a single game.
|
| Consistency (Silver) | In any game mode, strike out the side with the same out pitch, with the same pitcher.
|
| Craig "Blitzcraig" Kimbrel (Silver) | In any game mode with Craig Kimbrel, strike out 3 batters and earn the save in a single game.
|
| David "Captain America" Wright (Gold) | In any game mode with David Wright, hit 2 doubles, a triple, and a home run in a single game.
|
| Done! (Platinum) | Earn all of the MLB 14 The Show... Trophies.
|
| Extras Win! (Bronze) | In any game mode, win a game in extra innings.
|
| Fence Posts (Silver) | Score a single run in every inning of a full 9 inning game (excludes RTTS mode).
|
| Frozen (Bronze) | Strike out a batter looking in any game mode.
|
| Getting a Piece (Gold) | In any mode, excluding RTTS (and including Community Challenge mode), play an entire 9 inning game without striking out.
|
| Grand Salami (Bronze) | In any game mode, hit a grand slam.
|
| Jose "Gigante" Altuve (Gold) | In any game mode with Jose Altuve, get 3 hits and steal 3 bases in a single game.
|
| Knock Out Punch (Silver) | In any game mode, knock out the opponent's starting pitcher before the end of the 3rd inning (excludes any All-Star game, includes Community Challenge.
|
| Miguel "MC Hammer" Cabrera (Gold) | In any game mode with Miguel Cabrera, hit 3 home runs while having a perfect day at the plate in a single game.
|
| Mike "The Millville Meteor" Trout (Gold) | In any game mode with Mike Trout, hit for the cycle and steal a base in a single game.
|
| Patience is a Virtue (Bronze) | In any single plate appearance, see 10 or more pitches (includes Community Challenge mode).
|
| Paul "America's First Baseman" Goldschmidt (Silver) | In any game mode with Paul Goldschmidt, collect 4 hits, drive in 4 RBI, and score 4 runs in a single game.
|
| Socialite (Bronze) | Successfully complete another user's posted Community Challenge.
|
| Stephen "The Soul Crusher" Strasburg (Gold) | In any game mode with Stephen Strasburg, strike out 12 and allow no earned runs en route to the win.
|
| Walk Off (Bronze) | In any game mode, win a game on a walk off hit.
|
| Yasiel "The Wild Horse" Puig (Gold) | In any game mode with Yasiel Puig, hit a double, triple, and steal 2 bases in a single game.
|
| Yu "Brother Dal" Darvish (Silver) | In any game mode with Yu Darvish, throw 7 complete innings, strike out 14 en route to the win.
|