| Award | How to unlock | 
|---|
| 11th Hour Save | Win a match when your partner has less than 25% health remaining (tag team match). | 
| 4 Corners Of Doom | Successfully complete a corner grapple on all four corners. | 
| A Little Pick-me-up | Pick up downed opponent five times. | 
| All Heart | Take finishing moves from opponent and win. | 
| Armed Hammer | Bust a sledgehammer on opponent. | 
| Around The World | Execute five environmental grapples. | 
| Back-Breaking Labor | Execute seven submission moves to an opponent's torso. | 
| Blood Test | Bloody both opponents (tag team match). | 
| Blown Up | Get tired enough to fall down. | 
| Breaking Point | Bust four objects. | 
| By A Thread | Win a match with less than 10% health. | 
| Can't Catch Me | Taunt six times while out of the ring. | 
| Cardio Monster | Consume 400 units of stamina. | 
| Chain Wrestler | Successfully complete twenty quick grapples. | 
| Cheerleader | Pump up the crowd five times as the illegal partner (tag team match). | 
| Cheese With That Whine? | Argue with the ref four times. | 
| Continue The Pain | Manually halt the ref's pinfall count four times. | 
| Could've Ended Sooner | Perform your finisher four times. | 
| Crowd Can't See | Spend over thirty seconds fighting outside the ring. | 
| Cut The Wire | Bust a barbed wire 2x4 on an opponent. | 
| David Whups Goliath | Defeat a super-heavyweight in two and a half minutes or less while playing as a cruiser. | 
| Demolition Man | Destroy all the announcer tables. | 
| Diva Whups Goliath | Defeat a super-heavyweight in two and half minutes or less while playing as a diva. | 
| Don't Call It A Comeback | Win a match with less than 50% health. | 
| Drive-By Grapple | Successfully complete ten running grapples. | 
| Duke The Dumpster | Bust a trash can on opponent. | 
| Extreme Finisher | Perform two finishers outside the ring. | 
| Failure To Launch | Let top-momentum timer expire three times. | 
| Fear Of Flying | Climb the top rope four times and jump down rather than attacking. | 
| Flying Around The Ring | Hit top rope moves off every corner. | 
| Friendly Skies | Connect with ten attacks off the top rope. | 
| Fuji Would Be Proud | Successfully taunt your opponent eight times. | 
| Get Inside Now! | Stay out of the ring until the ref's nine-count. | 
| Greco-Roman Master | Do not use a strike the entire match. | 
| Haymaker | Connect with twelve standing strikes. | 
| Hey, Look At Me! | Distract referee four times (tag team match). | 
| High-Rent District | Hit top rope move to an opponent at ringside. | 
| Homage To The Dungeon | Perform five submission holds while out of the ring. | 
| I'm Not Done Yet | Counter two finisher attempts. | 
| Impenetrable Defense | Block or counter at least ten attacks/grapples. | 
| In Control | Execute five total control grapples. | 
| Insult To Injury | Successfully taunt your opponent four times. | 
| Invisible Superstar | Successfully complete a match without taking damage. | 
| Joyless Victory | Win with very little momentum. | 
| Lock Breaker | Escap four Struggle submissions during a match. | 
| Minimalist | Only use a total of three different attacks or grapples for the whole match. | 
| Minute Man | Win in under a minute. | 
| Mucho Lucha | Connect with five attacks off the top rope. | 
| No Cover Charge | Win without going for a single pin attempt. | 
| No Kitchen Sink? | Strike opponent with five different objects. | 
| No Seat For You! | Bust a chair on opponent. | 
| None Shall Pass | Reverse/counter every attack/grapple in a match. | 
| Not Paid By The Hour | Win in less than two and a half minutes. | 
| Obstructed View | Spend two minutes fighting outside of the ring. | 
| On Strike | Do not use a grapple the entire match. | 
| One-Trick Pony | Use one attack or grapple exclusively for an entire match. | 
| Out Of Control | Break out of three total control grapples by an opponent. | 
| Out Of Stock | Come up short looking for object under ring. | 
| Pain In The Neck | Execute seven submission moves to an opponent's neck. | 
| Personal Space | Never touch the ropes. | 
| Photo Opp | Successfully complete all your Superstar's signatures and finishers. | 
| Plasma Scream | Win while both you and opponent were bloody. | 
| Pretzel Maker | Execute a submission move to every part of an opponent's body. | 
| Ringland Security | Execute two grapples against the security barricade. | 
| Seeing Red | Win a match after being bloodied. | 
| Showing Mercy | Manually release six Struggle submissions (no rope break). | 
| Sideline Supporter | Successfully complete four strikes/grapples from the apron (tag team match). | 
| Singapore Superstar | Bust a Singapore cane on opponent. | 
| Sit In The Corner | Irish Whip opponent into corner ten times. | 
| Speed Bag Expert | Successfully complete 35 strikes. | 
| Squash Match | Win with 85% of your total health. | 
| Stay Down | Knock opponent down and never let them back up. | 
| Sticks & Stones... | Win despite being hit with three different objects. | 
| Stomp A Mudhole | Connect with eight strikes with opponent is in the corner. | 
| Strong Like Bull | Execute five strong grapples. | 
| Sugar Rush | Successfully complete ten running attacks. | 
| Suit Of Armor | Win without sustaining yellow limb damage anywhere. | 
| Sweep The Leg | Execute seven submission holds to an opponent's leg. | 
| Tabletop Tapout | Lock on a submission move while opponent is on an announcer table. | 
| Take One For The Team | Win a match when you have 33% health or less and your partner has 75% health or more (tag team match). | 
| Take Out The Trash | Irish Whip opponent outside ring three times. | 
| Take This Broken Wing | Execute seven submission holds to an opponent's arms. | 
| Taunt Faster, Poser! | Have a taunt interrupted by an opponent three times. | 
| The Human Autograph | Execute five signature moves. | 
| There Will Be Blood | Make an opponent bleed within one minute. | 
| Think You Overdid It? | Perform your finisher eight times. | 
| This Is My Yard | Never leave the ring. | 
| Too Many 2s | Win by pinfall after five two-counts by either superstar. | 
| Tougher Than Lumber | Win despite being put through a table (including announce table). | 
| Unpredictable Offense | Win while only being countered/revered three or fewer times. | 
| Unsafe Workspace | Destroy one of the announcer tables. | 
| Well-Oiled Machine | Perform seven double-team moves (tag team match). | 
| Whipper Snapper | Irish Whip opponent five times. | 
| Wipe The Smirk Off | Break up three taunt attempts by your opponent. | 
| You'll Hurt Yourself | Take an opponent's object three times. | 
| Ability | How to unlock | 
|---|
| Bloodshed | Make your opponents bleed ten times and bleed yourself ten times (rewarded on win with blood). | 
| Cage Match | Win a Cage match in under a minute by escaping. | 
| Dirty Pin | Get a "5 Star" rank against three different opponents who have this ability. | 
| Durability | Defeat a superstar rated 20 points higher overall while both having orange damage. | 
| Evasive Dodge | Win a Special match against two opponents. | 
| Fan Favorite | Successfully taunt ten times in a match (must not have steal taunt). | 
| Hammer Throw | Earn an ability within your first ten career matches, then get the "Sit In The Corner" award. | 
| K.O. | Earn a "5 Star" rank against every competitor in a title path, not including the title match. | 
| Kip-up | Win six championships. | 
| Ladder Match | Get a "5 Star" ranked Ladder match against one of the Hardys. | 
| Lock Pick | Face Y2J in a Singles match, and escape the Walls Of Jericho. | 
| Move Theft | Defeat twenty different superstars. | 
| Object Specialist (grab with object) | Execute fifty object attacks in your career. | 
| Outside Dives | Successfully complete twenty five dives in your career. | 
| Possum Pin | Defeat three superstars who have Possum Pin to get a sneaky pinfall, catching your opponent by surprise. | 
| Referee Shield | Get five DQ losses, then win a championship match against a clean superstar. | 
| Resiliency | Kick out of a pin at "2" while having two parts of red body damage. | 
| Springboard | Win the Cruiserweight Championship. | 
| Steal Taunt | Foil your opponent's attempt to steal your taunt (cannot have Fan Fave ability). | 
| Submission | Attempt seven Struggle Submissions in one match, and then win. | 
| Table Match | Break forty tables in your career (announcer tables count). | 
| Unlockable | How to Unlock | 
|---|
| Boogeyman as a playable character | Complete Undertaker's RTW | 
| Brothers of Destruction Entrance | Complete the bonus objective in Undertaker's RTW | 
| CAW Moveset 1 | In Batista/Rey's RTWM have Batista win the Rumble, Rey lose to Edge at NWO, and then have Rey lose the tag titles against Morrison and Miz. | 
| CAW Moveset 2 | In Batista/Rey's RTWM have Rey win the Rumble, Batista lose to Edge at NWO, and then have Batista lose the tag titles against Morrison and Miz | 
| CAW Moveset 3 | Pin Edge in the Triple Threat match during Triple H's RTW | 
| CM Punk black and white attire | Complete the bonus objective in CM Punk's RTW | 
| Code video for CAS | Call out Kennedy at NWO in Jerichos RTWM. Then bust Kennedy open the week before WM | 
| Curt Hawkins and Zack Ryder | Complete Bonus to spear Edge TWICE with Batista on Rey/Batista RtW Mode | 
| DX Attire (HBK & HHH) | Complete Triple H's DX path in RTWM | 
| DX music, video and entrance | Complete Triple H's DX path in RTW | 
| Evolution music, video and entrance | Complete Triple H's Evolution path in RTW | 
| Gauntlet match in Exhibition | Beat Mr. Kennedy in less than 2:30 in Cena's RTWM | 
| Hornswoggle as a manager | Complete the bonus objective in Undertaker's RTW | 
| Jericho's Attitude Era attire | Interrogate Jeff Hardy and defeat him without using a finisher in Week 6, 7, or 8 in Y2J's RTWM | 
| Jillian Hall as a playable superstar | Pin either London or Kendrick as Triple H in RTWM | 
| Layla | Beat Big Daddy V in under 2 Minutes and 30 seconds as Cm Punk in Road to Wrestlemania. | 
| Locker Room Brawl | Play as CM Punk, pin John Morrison in a Triple Threat match in week 10. | 
| Masked Man as a playable superstar | Complete Chris Jericho's RTWM | 
| Mr. McMahon as a playable superstar | Complete Batista & Rey Mysterio's RTWM with either superstar | 
| Rey Mysterio's Alternate Attire | Complete Bonus to pin John Morrison on Rey/Batista RtW Mode | 
| Ric Flair as a playable character | Complete Triple H's Evolution path in RTW | 
| Saturday Night's Main Event arena | Complete the bonus objective in Batista & Mysterio's RTWM Week 11 | 
| Snitsky as a playable superstar | Make MVP bleed in Cena's RTWM Week 11 | 
| Tazz as a playable character | Complete CM Punk's RTW | 
| Tony as a playable superstar | Complete the bonus objective on Cena's RTWM Week 7 | 
| Tribute to the Troops Arena | Complete the bonus objective in John Cena's RTW | 
| WCW Brand and Classic Championship Belt | Complete the bonus objective in Y2J's RTWM in Week 3 | 
| WCW Faction & WCW Heavyweight Belt | Pin Finlay in Week 3 in Jericho's RTWM | 
| Wrestlemania Jeep in Create-A-Superstar Entrance | Complete John Cena's RTWM | 
| Zombie Finlay | Help Rey win the match in Undertaker's RTWM | 
| Zombie Santino Marella | Undertaker's RTWM, Help Rey win the match in week 11. |