| Achievement | How to unlock
|
|---|
| Blackest Heart | Become the most despicable Marshal.
|
| Brought the Law | Bring the law to the frontier.
|
| Frontier Freedom | Don't put limitations on people.
|
| Hang the Law | Hang Marshals Steele and James.
|
| I am the Marshal | See things through in Lander county.
|
| K-Bar Award | Kill the bear.
|
| Love to Love | Love more than most.
|
| Master Betrayer | Betray Carson, Caraway, and Schmidt in one play-through.
|
| My Word is My Bond | Your word is your bond.
|
| No Rules to Play By | Don't accept anyone's rules.
|
| Ride That Bear! | Ride that grizzly bear!
|
| The Nameless Marshal | Your feats are legend though your name is lost.
|
| True Indian Friend | You are a true friend to the Indians.
|
| With an Iron Hand | You are the Marshal that brought order to the frontier.
|