| Achievement | How to unlock | Points
|
|---|
| A Good Toy | Place every shape correctly during Ms. Gracie's game. | 50
|
| All Your Fault | Escape Lily Lovebraids. | 25
|
| Avid Listener | Play every VHS tape. | 30
|
| Avid Reader | Collect all hidden documents. | 50
|
| Cassette Curator | Play every cassette tape. | 50
|
| Complete the Set | Collect all hidden Wrongside Outimals. | 50
|
| Each Sold Separately | Listen to all of Lily's cardboard cutouts. | 30
|
| Experiment 1170 | Experience Huggy Wuggy's memories. | 25
|
| Go For Gold | Collect all hidden trophies. | 30
|
| Going Down? | Escape Huggy Wuggy. | 25
|
| Guest of Honor | Escape Lily's Dollhouse without getting caught. | 50
|
| Guiding Light | Obtain Glowby. | 25
|
| Hand-Me-Down | Find a new GrabPack. | 25
|
| I Spin, You Spin | We all spin for ice cream! | 15
|
| Let There Be Light | Navigate Recycling without being attacked. | 50
|
| No Distractions | Enter Sweet Street after distracting Huggy with only one projector. | 50
|
| Now What's This? | Complete the game. | 50
|
| One Man Show | Encore! | 15
|
| Property Damage | You'll have to pay for that! | 15
|
| Protector | Listen to Giblet's cardboard cutout. | 15
|
| Reanimated | "Survive" the Prototype. | 50
|
| Self Restraint | Complete the game without launching your GrabPack hands more than 350 times. | 50
|
| Shoo! | Get out of here! | 15
|
| Starboard | Arrr! | 15
|
| Surgical Imprecision | Fail to thread the needle. | 15
|
| Toy of Few Words | Listen to Chum's cardboard cutout. | 15
|
| Trained Professional | Escape on the train without taking damage. | 50
|
| Unbroken | Complete the game without dying. | 50
|
| Until He Pops | Pop all golden balloons. | 50
|
| Wrongside Out | Listen to a secret song. | 15
|