| Achievement | How to unlock | Points
|
|---|
| #1 In Your Heart | Get drafted as the #1 overall draft pick in the MLB Draft. | 70
|
| A Robbery! | Rob a home run. (Excludes simulated gameplay) | 70
|
| Are You Still There? | Strikeout without swinging the bat during an at-bat. | 20
|
| Baseball is Better Together | Play an online or couch co-op game. | 20
|
| Can of Corn | Catch five fly balls in a single game. | 20
|
| Defensive Run Saved | As a defender, throw a player out at home plate. | 40
|
| Don't Call it a Rally | After entering an inning when losing, get five hits during that same inning. | 40
|
| Down Low... Too Slow | Use a swim move to avoid a tag while sliding into a base. | 40
|
| Flush | While playing Diamond Quest, buy two perks from Coach's Cart on a single map. | 40
|
| GOAT MODE | Get a Hit or Strikeout while playing on GOAT difficulty. | 70
|
| Going Gold | Achieve "Gold" in any mini game within Road to the Show. | 70
|
| Gone Questing | Successfully Complete a Diamond Quest Map Run. | 40
|
| Horses in the Pen | Set an opening pitcher for a bullpen game in Franchise. | 40
|
| I Don't Need It | In Road to the Show, have fifty Show Tokens in your inventory at once. | 40
|
| Moving Up the Board | In Road to the Show, choose to go to college and come out with a higher draft stock than before. | 20
|
| NLB Historian '26 | Complete four Negro League Storylines. | 70
|
| Patience is Golden | As a batter, draw a walk. | 20
|
| Rally Cap | After entering an inning when losing, get 7 hits during that same inning. | 70
|
| Suit Up | In Road to the Show, equip a piece of equipment in every slot. | 40
|
| Swing Batter Batter | Take your first swing in MLB The Show 26. | 20
|
| THE SHOW 2-6 | Register a 2-6 out during a game. | 40
|
| The Start of Something | After entering an inning when losing, get three hits during that same inning. | 20
|
| This is My Home | Play in a user created stadium. | 20
|
| Who's the New Kid? | Get a hit against or strikeout any former MLB The Show cover athlete. | 20
|
| You're Sure They Meant Me? | Score a run with a pinch runner that has 26 speed or lower. | 40
|