| Achievement | How to unlock | Points
|
|---|
| A Traitor's Coat | Defeat the ghost of Captain James Ramsey. | 100
|
| Cultist's Rise | Break the Soul Jar. | 100
|
| Mark Keeper's Triumph | Leave the island as captain, saving every pirate and old folk you can from the doom of the island. | 200
|
| Mermaids at Sea | Save every Angry Mermaid Pirate found alive. | 150
|
| Old Folk's Legacy | Leave the island with Tim, Yonis, Okiros and The Guru. | 75
|
| Pursue the Journey | Rekindle the Ancient Crossroads Central Shrine. | 25
|
| Ready for Anything | Unlock all Trinkets. | 125
|
| Recording History | Read all Stone Tablets found on the Island. | 75
|
| The Intriguing Stone Tablet | Find Yonis, along with three Stone Tablets. | 50
|
| The Most Essential Artifact | Help Mei get back together with her crew by handing her the Jade Crown. | 100
|