| Character | Task
|
|---|
| Abyss | Progress through Story mode.
|
| AJ Styles X | Progress through Story mode.
|
| Brother Devon | Progress through Story mode.
|
| Chris Sabin X | Progress through Story mode.
|
| Consequences Creed | Complete the game and watch the credits.
|
| Eric Young | Progress through Story mode.
|
| Jay Lethal | Progress through Story mode.
|
| Jeff Jarret | Progress through Story mode.
|
| Kevin Nash | Progress through Story mode.
|
| Mick Foley | Win the 25 Man Gauntlet match.
|
| Petey Williams | Progress through Story mode.
|
| Sonjay Dutt | Progress through Story mode.
|
| Suicide | Progress through Story mode.
|
| Suicide X | Progress through Story mode.
|
| Tomko | Progress through Story mode.
|