| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| All Baine, No Pain | Hear all of Baines puns. | Gold
|
| Beach You To It | Beat Asta's first challenge. | Gold
|
| Electrifying | Restore power to the lighthouse. | Bronze
|
| Far Out Dude | Beat Asta's third challenge. | Gold
|
| Fin-Tastic! | Beat Asta's fourth challenge. | Gold
|
| Good Things Come To Those Who Bait | Meet the shadow hunter. | Silver
|
| Its A-Boat Time | Leave Night Orchard. | Silver
|
| Keepin' It Ship-Shape | Save all gloomed up ships. | Gold
|
| Oh Buoy! | Set off to see the pirates. | Gold
|
| Riding The Wave | Beat Asta's second challenge. | Gold
|
| Seal Your Gloom | Stop the drilling. | Silver
|
| Shell Yeah! | Save Sleepy Triplets. | Gold
|
| Turning The Tide | Complete the story. | Gold
|
| Water We Doing Here? | Return to Night Orchard. | Gold
|
| Water-Logged | Complete the game and collect all trophies. | Platinum
|