| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| Arcade Regular | Win a match on Medium difficulty. | Gold
|
| Center Line Chaos | During a single rally (no goal scored), have the puck cross the center line 25 times. | Gold
|
| Classy in the Arcade | Buy the Fedora Hat. | Silver
|
| Claw & Order | Buy the Claw Machine. | Gold
|
| Cold Streak | Lose a match. | Gold
|
| Cosmic Quarter-Eater | Buy the Astro Machine. | Silver
|
| Foosball Fixture | Buy the Foosball Machine. | Silver
|
| Golden Finish | Buy the Gold Trophy. | Gold
|
| Out of Order, In Your Corner | Buy the Broken Arcade Machine. | Gold
|
| PUCK RUSH: Platinum League | Unlock all trophies in Puck Rush. | Platinum
|
| Popcorn Powered | Buy the Popcorn Machine. | Silver
|
| Shelf-Made | Buy the Wooden Shelf. | Silver
|
| Shutout-ish | Win a match while the AI scores 0–2 goals. | Gold
|
| Sweet Tooth Setup | Buy the Gumball Machine. | Silver
|
| Table Titan | Win a match on Hard difficulty. | Gold
|
| Training Wheels Champion | Win a match on Easy difficulty. | Bronze
|
| Wrapped & Ready | Buy the Gift Box. | Gold
|