| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| 5-Pointer | Score 5 points from a 50+ yard field goal. | Bronze
|
| Ace in the hole | Collect a Legend Card reward. | Silver
|
| Addicted | Use all SkillRoids available in the game. | Bronze
|
| All according to the plan | Perform Onside Kick and receive the ball with the same player who performed the kick. | Bronze
|
| Assassin | Kill 100 opposing players! | Bronze
|
| Back 2 Back | Win 2 consecutive Mayhem Bowls in the Dynasty Supreme game mode. | Bronze
|
| Bloodbath Massacre | The play results in a total of 10 or more players dead (friendly players counts as well). | Bronze
|
| Card Shark | Collect 25 player card rewards. | Bronze
|
| Catch! | Win a single game using passing plays. | Bronze
|
| Cheap Shot | Kill 10 players with late hits! | Bronze
|
| Clusterfk | Score a clusterfk. | Bronze
|
| Collect all SkillRoids | Collect all Skillroids. | Silver
|
| Control Freak | Win a game without turning over the ball. | Bronze
|
| Dynasty | Win 5 consecutive Mayhem Bowls in the Dynasty Supreme game mode. | Silver
|
| Everyone has a price | Bribe 100 refs. | Bronze
|
| Exterminator | Kill 1000 opposing players! | Bronze
|
| Fancy Footwork | Win a single game using only running plays. | Bronze
|
| First Blood | Get your first kill in the MFL. | Bronze
|
| Flip the Script | Go from trailing to 14 points to leading by 14 points. | Bronze
|
| Foursome | Win 4 consecutive Mayhem Bowls in the Dynasty Supreme game mode. | Silver
|
| From Scrub to Stud | Develop a Rookie player into a All-Star player in the Dynasty Supreme game mode. | Gold
|
| Game Master | Obtain all trophies. | Platinum
|
| God of Mayhem | Win the Mayhem Bowl on All-Star Massochist (in Season or Dynasty Supreme game modes). | Silver
|
| Halftime Hall-of-famer | Win 100 halftime show minigames. | Silver
|
| I Am Legend | Build a player to Legend status in the Dynasty Supreme game mode. | Silver
|
| In memorium | Have 500 players on your team die. | Bronze
|
| Killer | Kill 10 opposing players! | Bronze
|
| Klepto | Intercept 50 passes. | Silver
|
| Massacre | Win a game by forfeit! | Bronze
|
| Master of Mayhem | Win the Mayhem Bowl on All-Pro (in Season or Dynasty Supreme game modes). | Bronze
|
| More than just a Kicker | Score TD or 2 points conversion via run, throwing or catching pass on a fake play by the Kicker. | Bronze
|
| Pack Attack | Collect a pack of cards reward. | Bronze
|
| Perfect Punt delivery | Return Punt for a TD as receiving team. | Bronze
|
| Perfect logistics manager | Return 3 or more Kickoffs or punts for TDs in a single match as receiving team. | Bronze
|
| Perfect return delivery | Return Kickoff for a TD as receiving team. | Bronze
|
| Phenomenom | Score 1000 of popularity points. | Bronze
|
| Play God | Win a game with Custom Team. | Bronze
|
| Playbook Guru | Make a custom playbook with 8 formations and 8 plays per formation on Offense and Defense in the Dynasty Supreme game mode. | Silver
|
| Popularity Contest | Score 300 of popularity points in a single game. | Bronze
|
| Projectile Dysfunction | Complete 8 or more interceptions in a single match. | Bronze
|
| Rage Against the Machine | Win a game against the AI set to All-Star Masochist. | Silver
|
| Rising Stars | Win the Mayhem Bowl with a custom team in Dynasty Supreme or Season game modes. | Bronze
|
| Sack'em up | Complete 10 or more Sacks in a single match. | Bronze
|
| Say yes to drugs | Use 10 skillroids in a single game. | Bronze
|
| Serial Murder | Kill 5 players in 1 Murder Ball pass. | Bronze
|
| Trifecta | Win 3 consecutive Mayhem Bowls in the Dynasty Supreme game mode. | Silver
|
| Undefeated | Perfection - undefeated season with Mayhem Bowl win in the Dynasty Supreme game mode. | Gold
|
| We Are (All) the Champions | Win the Mayhem Bowl with every MFL Pro-League teams in the Dynasty Supreme, Season or Playoff game modes. | Silver
|
| Zebra Hunter | Kill 100 Referees. | Bronze
|