| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| 40/40 Watch? | Hit a home run and steal a base with the same player in one game. (Excludes moments, simulated gameplay, joining game moments in progress) | Gold
|
| A Double Play Would Be Nice Here | Get a double play to end the inning. (Excludes simulated gameplay) | Bronze
|
| Ambush! | Get a hit with the first pitch of the game. | Silver
|
| Celebrity Shot | Drive in a run with a pinch hitter. | Bronze
|
| Champion Of The Diamond! | Achieve all Trophies in MLB The Show 24. | Platinum
|
| Chin Up Champ | As a pitcher, give up a hit on the first at-bat of an inning and then strike out the next batter. (Excludes simulated gameplay) | Bronze
|
| Derby Level Damage | Hit a home run over 460 ft. | Bronze
|
| Empty the Tank | Get a strikeout with no Energy remaining. | Silver
|
| Good Grelief | With the bases loaded and nobody out, strike out three in a row without a run scoring to end the inning. (Excludes simulated gameplay) | Gold
|
| Gotta Be Quicker Than That | Throw out a runner going for extra bases. (Excludes simulated gameplay) | Bronze
|
| If You Stare, it Might Stay Fair | Hit a ball that can leave the field on either side of the foul pole. | Bronze
|
| Kitchen Sink | Strike a batter out by throwing at least four different pitches during the same at-bat. (Excludes simulated gameplay) | Silver
|
| Living On the Field | Play and finish 24 games of at least 3 innings within any mode. (Excludes moments, simulated gameplay, joining game moments in progress) | Gold
|
| Maddux | Using a single pitcher, win a complete game in under 100 pitches in a full 9-inning game. (Excludes moments, simulated gameplay, joining game moments in progress) | Gold
|
| Open the Tool Box | Use two bench players in a single game. (Excludes moments, simulated gameplay, joining game moments in progress) | Silver
|
| Pure Speed | Have a runner score from first without the baseball leaving the field of play. | Silver
|
| Red Hot Baserunning | In a single inning steal second, third, and score with the same player. | Gold
|
| Save Some for Tomorrow | Win a game by 24 or more runs. (Excludes simulated gameplay) | Gold
|
| Setting the Tone | Strike out the first batter of the game. | Bronze
|
| Speed or Luck or Both? | Hit a triple. (Excludes simulated gameplay) | Silver
|
| Stay in School | Watch a STATCAST presentation. | Bronze
|
| Supposed to be My Day Off | Have your closer get a one-out save. (Excludes simulated gameplay) | Bronze
|
| Swan Dive Defense | Make a diving catch for an out. (Excludes simulated gameplay) | Silver
|
| The Best Offense is No Offense | Score a run without getting a hit (have a run score off a walk, error, or sac fly). (Excludes simulated gameplay) | Silver
|
| Trading Places | With only a runner on second base, hit an RBI double. (Excludes simulated gameplay) | Silver
|
| Walk Off, Do Your Dance | Win the game on a walk-off home run. | Silver
|