| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| A Chase through the Night | Completed "An Offer You Can't Refuse". | Bronze
|
| A Life of Crime | Completed the game on Easy, Medium, or Hard difficulty. | Gold
|
| A View from the Top | Completed "Election Campaign". | Bronze
|
| Best Laid Plans | Completed "Great Deal". | Bronze
|
| Blood on Beech Hill | Completed "Visiting Rich People". | Bronze
|
| Car Enthusiast | Lockpicked five cars on the streets of Lost Heaven and environs. | Bronze
|
| Car Thief Number One | Found all of the hidden cars. | Silver
|
| Comic Violence | Found a copy of Gangsters Monthly. | Bronze
|
| Death on the Water | Completed "Happy Birthday". | Bronze
|
| Family History | Found a 'Gangsters of the United States' cigarette card. | Bronze
|
| Friends and Family | Completed "The Death of Art". | Bronze
|
| Full Set | Found all 'Gangsters of the United States' cigarette cards. | Silver
|
| Gangs of Lost Heaven | Completed "Ordinary Routine". | Bronze
|
| Good Night for a Walk Anyways | Completed "Sarah". | Bronze
|
| Heat from the Cops | Lost the cops after accruing a five star police chase. | Bronze
|
| Into the Lion's Den | Completed "Just For Relaxation". | Bronze
|
| Lending Library | Found all Pulp Magazines. | Silver
|
| Lined Pockets | Paid a fine to the Lost Heaven Police Department. | Bronze
|
| Made Man | Completed the game on Classic difficulty. | Gold
|
| Motor Museum | Collected thirty vehicles in the Garage. | Silver
|
| Murder in the House of God | Completed "The Saint and the Sinner". | Bronze
|
| Mystery Fox Discovered | Found a Mystery Fox. | Bronze
|
| Mystery Fox Domination | Found all Mystery Foxes. | Silver
|
| Neighborhood Hero | Completed "Fair Play". | Bronze
|
| Not Classy | Took Paulie to a Place of Disrepute. | Bronze
|
| Not Taken In | Resisted arrest by the Lost Heaven Police Department. | Bronze
|
| On the Trail | Found a hidden car. | Bronze
|
| Picture Book Connoisseur | Found all copies of Gangsters Monthly. | Silver
|
| Pulp Fiction | Found a Pulp Magazine. | Bronze
|
| Quite the Collection | Collected fifteen vehicles in the Garage. | Bronze
|
| Rat in the House | Completed "Omerta". | Bronze
|
| Storm Cloud over Chinatown | Completed "Better Get Used to It". | Bronze
|
| Stunt Rider | Performed a wheelie for three seconds. | Bronze
|
| Supercharged | Won the race. | Silver
|
| That Last Big Score | Completed "Moonlighting". | Bronze
|
| That Motor can Move | Reached 50mph while driving the Bolt Ace. | Bronze
|
| The Back Streets of Little Italy | Completed "Running Man". | Bronze
|
| The Day the War Began | Completed "Bon Appétit". | Bronze
|
| The Day the War Ended | Completed "Crème de la Crème". | Bronze
|
| The Original Gangster | Obtained all Mafia: Definitive Edition Trophies. | Platinum
|
| The Way this City Works | Completed "Molotov Party". | Bronze
|
| The Whole Story | Completed the Collection. | Gold
|
| When God Stops Smiling | Completed "You Lucky ..." | Bronze
|
| Your Canuck Cousins | Completed "A Trip to the Country". | Bronze
|